Best Website Builders Compared 2024: Expert Guide to Choosing Right

So you want to build a website? Yeah, I remember being in your shoes a few years back. Scrolling through endless options, completely overwhelmed by all the "easy" website builders promising the moon. Truth is, not all platforms are created equal, and choosing the wrong one can literally cost you hundreds of dollars and dozens of wasted hours. Been there, done that - built a photography portfolio on a platform that charged extra for every basic feature. What a nightmare.

After building over 50 sites for clients and personal projects, I've learned exactly where each website builder shines and where they fall flat. Forget the marketing fluff. We're digging into what actually works for real people who just want to make a great website without becoming tech experts overnight.

Why You Should Care About Choosing the Right Website Builder

Picking a random website builder because it has a flashy ad? Bad idea. These platforms lock you into their ecosystem. Transferring your site later is like moving houses with superglue on all your furniture - messy and painful. I learned this the hard way when a client demanded migration from Wix to WordPress. Took three full days of manual work.

The real question isn't "can I make a website" but "what happens after I launch?" Will you get stuck paying $25/month for features others include for $10? Can you actually rank on Google? Does it load fast or feel like dial-up? These things matter way more than pretty templates.

Cracking the Code: Understanding Website Builder Types

Not all platforms for making websites operate the same way. Some give you Lego blocks, others hand you a lump of clay. Know the difference:

Visual Builders (Drag & Drop): Think Wix, Squarespace. Click elements and move them anywhere. Super intuitive but can get messy for complex layouts. Great for beginners who value design freedom over technical control.
Structured Builders: Like Shopify or Weebly. They use section-based editing where you choose pre-defined content blocks. Less flexible but harder to break. Perfect if you want guardrails preventing design disasters.
Open-Source Platforms: WordPress.org falls here. You install it on your own hosting. Total freedom but requires more technical management. That moment when a plugin update breaks your contact form at 2AM? Yeah, not fun.

My Personal Experience With Different Builders

When I launched my first consulting site, I chose Squarespace. Beautiful templates, but their blogging functionality felt like typing with oven mitts on. Switched to WordPress and never looked back, though the setup was intimidating initially. For e-commerce? Shopify hands down - their payment processing just works without constant tinkering.

Detailed Breakdown: Top 7 Websites to Make a Website

These are the platforms I've actually used professionally, not just tested once. Let's get into the gritty details:

Wix - The Freedom Builder

Wix is like digital Play-Doh - mold anything anywhere. That blank canvas is liberating until you realize elements snap to invisible grids when you're not looking. Their ADI (Artificial Design Intelligence) tool is surprisingly good if you're starting from absolute zero.

What I like: True drag-and-drop, huge template selection, built-in logo maker
What drives me nuts: Can't switch templates after launch, mobile editing requires constant adjustment
Hidden costs: Remove Wix ads ($16/month), accept online payments ($27/month)
Best for: Portfolio sites, small service businesses, restaurants

Squarespace - Design Perfectionists

Squarespace templates are gorgeous. Seriously, they make anything you build look pro. But try adding a simple contact form with conditional logic? You'll be knee-deep in code injection territory. Their e-commerce suddenly gets expensive once you enable checkouts.

What I like: Stunning designs, all-in-one platform, great blogging for visuals
Dealbreaker: Form builder limitations, rigid section structures
Pricing reality: Starts at $16/month but requires $46/month plan for full e-commerce
Best for: Artists, photographers, designers, aesthetic-focused brands

Shopify - The E-Commerce Engine

Built a dropshipping store with Shopify last year. Their abandoned cart recovery alone paid for the subscription twice over. But beware app creep - it's easy to rack up $100/month in add-ons for basic functionality.

Why it dominates: Payment processing (no third-party gateways needed), inventory management, shipping labels
Pain point: Blog functionality feels tacked on, rigid page layouts
Real cost: $29/month base + $10-50/month in essential apps
Best for: Any online store beyond 10 products

WordPress.org - The Scalable Powerhouse

Runs 43% of all websites for a reason. Complete control means you can build literally anything... if you're willing to climb the learning curve. Hosting costs extra ($3-$30/month) and you manage security/updates.

Unbeatable strengths: Endless plugins (55,000+), full SEO control, own your data
Downsides: Steeper learning curve, vulnerability to bad plugins
Essential tools: SiteGround hosting ($3.99/month), Elementor Pro ($49/year), RankMath SEO (free)
Best for: Blogs, businesses planning to scale, SEO-focused sites

Weebly - The Underrated All-Rounder

Square bought them and quietly made huge improvements. Their editor is what Wix would be with guardrails. Built-in email marketing and surprisingly robust e-commerce at lower tiers. Lacks the "wow" factor but gets the job done reliably.

Hidden gems: Free plan with Square ads (good for testing), built-in lead capture forms
Missing pieces: Limited third-party integrations, dated template designs
Price sweet spot: $12/month for full features minus e-commerce
Best for: Service businesses, local shops, simple online stores

The Brutally Honest Comparison Table

Numbers don't lie. Here's how the top platforms stack up where it actually matters:

Platform Starting Price Transaction Fees Loading Speed* Mobile Score* SEO Friendliness
Wix $16/month 2.9% + 30¢ (without plan) 2.8s (desktop) 68/100 Good basic options
Squarespace $16/month 3% (basic commerce) 1.9s (desktop) 89/100 Limited URL control
Shopify $29/month 0% with Shopify Payments 1.7s (desktop) 92/100 Solid product SEO
WordPress $3.99 + hosting Depends on payment gateway 0.8s (optimized) 95/100 Complete control
Weebly Free (with ads) 3% (free plan) 2.1s (desktop) 87/100 Basic canonical tags

*Based on GTmetrix testing with identical demo sites

Critical Features Most Beginners Overlook

It's not about flashy templates. These under-the-hood factors make or break your site long-term:

SEO Capabilities: Can You Actually Rank?

Built a beautiful site that Google ignores? Ouch. Essential SEO features:

  • Custom URL slugs (avoid /page123)
  • Automatic sitemaps
  • Schema markup support
  • 301 redirect management
  • Image alt text bulk editing

WordPress wins here with plugins like Yoast. Shopify handles product SEO well. Avoid platforms blocking access to .htaccess files.

Mobile Responsiveness: Not Optional

Google penalizes poor mobile experiences. Test thoroughly:

  • Text remains readable without zooming
  • Buttons spaced for thumb tapping
  • No horizontal scrolling nightmares
  • Images resize proportionally

Pro tip: Builders like Squarespace handle this automatically. With Wix, you MUST manually check mobile view.

My Mobile Testing Fail: Launched a client site looking perfect on desktop. Didn't check mobile thoroughly. Their phone number displayed as (555) 123-456 on desktop but became 555123456 on mobile. Lost them 30+ calls before we caught it. Always test on actual devices!

Loading Speed: The Silent Killer

Visitors bounce if pages take over 3 seconds to load. Factors affecting speed:

  • Platform infrastructure (Shopify/Wix use CDNs)
  • Image optimization tools
  • Code minification options
  • Caching systems

WordPress sites can be fastest but require optimization plugins. All-in-one platforms handle this better for beginners.

Cost Traps and Pricing Psychology

Website builder pricing feels deliberately confusing. Let's decode it:

The Tiered Pricing Game

Most use "good/better/best" pricing with artificial limitations:

  • Personal Plan: Usually removes ads but lacks core features ($10-16/month)
  • Business Plan: Adds e-commerce and analytics ($22-30/month)
  • VIP Plan: Often includes pointless "priority support" ($40+/month)

Essential add-ons they don't highlight:

  • Custom domain ($12-20/year)
  • Email hosting ($6/month extra)
  • Premium templates ($50+ one-time)
  • Storage upgrades (after 10GB)

My Money-Saving Tactics

After overpaying for years, here's what works:

  • Annual billing: Saves 20-30% immediately
  • Stack coupons: Search "(Builder Name) promo code 2024" before checkout
  • Buy domains separately: Use Namecheap instead of platform markup
  • Cancel during trials: Often triggers retention discounts

Website Builder Selection Flowchart

Still unsure? Answer these questions:

What's your primary goal?
  ├── Sell products → Shopify
  ├── Generate leads → Wix/Weebly
  ├── Blog/content creation → WordPress
  └── Showcase portfolio → Squarespace

Technical comfort level?
  ├── "I barely use email" → Wix ADI
  ├── "I can follow YouTube tutorials" → Squarespace
  └── "I enjoy tinkering" → WordPress

Budget constraints?
  ├── Under $150/year → Weebly/WordPress
  └── Over $300/year → Premium Shopify/WordPress

Real User Questions Answered

"Can I switch builders later without losing everything?"

Short answer: It's painful. Long answer: You can migrate content but designs won't transfer. Expect to manually rebuild templates. Export options vary:

  • WordPress: Full database export
  • Wix/Squarespace: Only basic page content exports
  • Shopify: Products/customers export well

Migrated a client from Squarespace to WordPress last month. Took 40 hours for a 50-page site. Choose wisely upfront!

"Are free website builders actually usable?"

Depends on your tolerance for:

  • Branded subdomains (yourbusiness.wixsite.com)
  • Platform ads in footers
  • Storage limits (usually 500MB-2GB)
  • No custom email addresses

Free plans work for testing ideas or temporary sites. Not viable professionally.

"Which platform ranks best on Google?"

Technically, all can rank. But WordPress dominates for serious SEO because:

  • Complete control over technical SEO factors
  • Advanced plugins (Rank Math, Yoast)
  • Faster loading speeds when optimized
  • Better schema markup implementation

That said, I've ranked Wix sites too. Requires more creative workarounds.

DIY vs Hiring a Pro: When to Jump

Built my first site solo. Looked like a Geocities relic circa 1998. Should've hired help. Here's when to consider pros:

  • Complex functionality needed: Custom booking systems, membership areas
  • Brand consistency critical: Corporate sites needing exact color matches
  • Migration projects: Moving between platforms without SEO damage
  • Time > Money: If your hourly rate exceeds $75, outsourcing makes sense

Most small businesses can self-serve with quality templates. Use platforms' built-in support when stuck.

Action Plan: Your First 24 Hours

Stop researching endlessly. Here's your launch sequence:

  1. Pick 1 platform based on core purpose (don't overthink)
  2. Claim your domain name immediately (Namecheap or Cloudflare)
  3. Start free trial with your chosen website builder
  4. Install 1 template closest to your vision (don't customize yet)
  5. Add real content to 3 key pages (Home, About, Contact)
  6. Preview mobile view and fix spacing issues
  7. Connect domain before trial ends to avoid rebuilds

The magic happens after launch. Tweak based on real user feedback, not hypothetical perfectionism. My first site had typos on every page. Still got clients because it existed.

Future-Proofing Your Website

Built a site in 2018 that now requires complete overhaul. Learned these lessons:

  • Own your domain: Register with independent provider (not the website builder)
  • Regular exports: Backup content monthly (especially blogs)
  • Avoid proprietary tech: Steer clear of platforms requiring special viewers
  • Document logins: Use a password manager for all accounts

The best websites to make a website balance simplicity today with flexibility tomorrow. Start simple, but leave room to grow beyond templates when needed.

Leave a Comments

Recommended Article