You know that feeling when your town's main street has more "for lease" signs than actual businesses? Or when the factory that employed half the community shuts down? That's exactly why my neighbor Bob and I got fed up and started researching economic improvement councils five years ago. After helping three towns set up their own EICs (Economic Improvement Councils), I've seen what works and what turns into a glorified coffee club. Let's cut through the jargon.
What Exactly is an Economic Improvement Council?
An Economic Improvement Council (EIC) isn't some mysterious government entity. Think of it as a task force on steroids - local business owners, educators, and regular folks rolling up their sleeves to boost their community's economy. Unlike chambers of commerce which focus on existing businesses, an economic improvement council tackles bigger picture stuff.
Here's what our council in Cedar Falls actually does:
- Attracts new employers (we landed a tech startup that created 85 jobs last year)
- Redevelops blighted areas (converted an old mall into mixed-use space)
- Trains workers for in-demand skills (partnered with community college)
- Streamlines business permits (cut approval times from 6 weeks to 10 days)
Core Functions That Make Economic Improvement Councils Effective
The economic improvement council concept only works if it moves beyond talk. These are the non-negotiables:
| Function | Real-World Example | Time Commitment | Typical Costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Recruitment | Creating targeted incentives for specific industries | 15-20 hrs/month | $5k-$15k annually |
| Workforce Development | Sponsoring certification programs with local schools | 10 hrs/month | $3k-$8k per program |
| Infrastructure Advocacy | Lobbying for highway exits or broadband expansion | Variable | Mostly volunteer hours |
| Small Business Support | Running "startup bootcamps" with legal/pro mentors | 8 hrs/month | $2k-$5k per event |
Honestly? Many newly formed economic improvement councils focus too much on ribbon cuttings and not enough on tangible outcomes. That's why funding sources dry up after year one.
Setting Up Your Economic Improvement Council: Step-by-Step
When we started our first economic improvement council, we made every mistake in the book. Save yourself the headache:
Phase 1: Pre-Launch (Months 1-2)
First, gather your founding members. We learned the hard way that inviting only "big shots" creates an echo chamber. Our core team included:
- A restaurateur who knew every business owner downtown
- A community college administrator
- Two skeptical manufacturing managers (their buy-in was crucial)
- A retired accountant to handle finances
- Me - just a guy tired of seeing his hometown decline
The paperwork varies by state. In Ohio, filing as a 501(c)(3) cost $850 and took 4 months. Some towns operate their economic improvement council under municipal government - faster setup but more red tape.
Phase 2: First-Year Action Plan
Your economic improvement council will die without early wins. Here's our battle-tested priority list:
| Quarter | Critical Actions | Budget Allocation | Measurement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Establish branding, digital presence, stakeholder interviews | 15% of budget | Stakeholder engagement metrics |
| Q2 | Launch 1 workforce program, begin business retention visits | 30% of budget | Participant numbers, business feedback |
| Q3 | Implement quick-win regulatory reforms, recruitment outreach | 40% of budget | Policy changes, prospect meetings |
| Q4 | Report outcomes, secure next-year funding, strategic planning | 15% of budget | Funding commitments, plan completion |
We almost tanked our council by trying to do everything at once. Pick three maximum focus areas year one. Seriously.
The moment we stopped meeting in fancy conference rooms and started using the back booth at Lou's Diner? That's when the real work began.
Funding Your Economic Improvement Council: Reality Check
Let's talk dollars because underfunded councils become irrelevant fast. Our economic improvement council operates on $175k/year - not huge but we make it count.
| Funding Source | Pros | Cons | Typical Range | Our Experience |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Municipal Allocation | Stable, legitimizes council | Political vulnerability | $20k-$250k | Provides 40% of our budget |
| Business Memberships | Builds stakeholder buy-in | Hard to scale | $500-$10k per biz | 25% of budget - tiered pricing works |
| Grants (Public/Private) | Project-specific funding | Time-intensive applications | Varies widely | 30% - requires dedicated grant writer |
| Events & Services | Self-sustaining elements | Can distract from mission | $5k-$50k | 5% - we keep this minimal |
A consultant once told us to pursue corporate sponsorships aggressively. Waste of time for smaller communities - stick to what works locally.
Top 5 Mistakes That Kill Economic Improvement Councils
Having watched three councils fail locally, I'd call these silent killers:
- The "Advisory Only" Trap - No authority = no results. Demand decision-making power on economic policies.
- Ignoring Data - That workforce training program we loved? Job placement stats showed 22% success. We killed it.
- Political Capture - When the mayor's cousin gets all the contracts, trust evaporates.
- Volunteer Burnout - We lost our best member because we kept assigning "homework". Staff key roles.
- Chasing Shiny Objects - Focus beats chasing every grant opportunity and trendy initiative.
Our county commissioner famously said: "Another damn committee?" That changed when we showed how our economic improvement council's permit streamlining brought in $3M in new business investment within 18 months.
Measuring Success: Beyond the Hype
Press releases lie. Real economic improvement council metrics look like this:
| Metric Category | What to Track | Measurement Frequency | Benchmarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Growth | New business openings, expansion projects, retention rate | Quarterly | 5% annual growth target |
| Employment | Jobs created, wage increases, underemployment rates | Bi-annually | Match regional averages |
| Investment | Capital expenditures, commercial vacancies, property values | Annual | 10% vacancy reduction |
| Efficiency Gains | Permit processing times, regulatory compliance costs | Monthly | 50% time reduction |
We learned transparency builds credibility. Our dashboard updates monthly on the town website - warts and all.
Economic Improvement Council FAQs
Who typically leads an economic improvement council?
In our case, a paid executive director (salary $65k-$85k) handles day-to-day operations. But the board chair must be a respected business leader - not a politician.
How do we prevent it from becoming another bureaucratic layer?
Sunset clauses. Every program we launch automatically expires in 24 months unless renewed with performance data. Ruthless but effective.
What's the ideal size for an economic improvement council board?
Bigger isn't better. We function best with 9 voting members - any more and decision-making paralyzes. Term limits prevent stagnation.
Can small towns afford this?
Absolutely. Our neighboring town's economic improvement council runs on $42k/year. They partner with regional groups for recruitment and share grant writers.
How political should it be?
You need political connections but shouldn't be political. We require members to resign if running for office. Partisanship kills coalitions.
Technology Tools That Actually Help
After wasting $12k on fancy software, here's what delivers real value:
- GIS Mapping - Visualizing vacancies and infrastructure gaps ($1,500/year)
- Simple CRM - Tracking business contacts and touchpoints (HubSpot free tier)
- Economic Dashboard - Public data visualization (Tableau Public - free)
- Project Management - Asana for task tracking ($6/member/month)
Skip the "economic development platforms" costing $20k+. They overpromise.
When to Hire Staff vs. Using Volunteers
Early on, our economic improvement council was all volunteers. Then progress stalled. Here's the staffing evolution:
| Annual Budget | Essential Hires | Compensation Range | Our Mistake to Avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under $50k | Part-time coordinator (20 hrs/week) | $25k-$35k | Hiring a general admin instead of someone with economic development experience |
| $50k-$150k | Full-time director + pt. support | $60k-$85k + $20k | Letting the board micromanage operations |
| $150k+ | Director + business development manager | $130k-$180k total | Creating silos between roles |
Truth moment: Pay below market = high turnover = lost institutional knowledge. Budget accordingly.
Legal Landmines Every Economic Improvement Council Faces
Our attorney still jokes about our "creative" early approaches. Key considerations:
- Antitrust Issues - Business recruitment discussions can accidentally cross lines. Document everything.
- FOIA Compliance - Even as a nonprofit, most communications are public record. Assume everything is readable.
- Incentive Structures - Tax abatements must follow strict formulas. We standardized ours after legal challenges.
- Contracting - Bidding requirements vary by municipality. We learned after a failed audit.
An ounce of prevention: Budget $5k-$10k annually for legal review. That contract template from another economic improvement council? Probably outdated or jurisdictionally invalid.
The biggest surprise? How much businesses appreciate clear rules. Uncertainty scares investors more than taxes.
Regional Collaboration: Force Multiplier Strategy
Our economic improvement council now partners with three counties on workforce initiatives. Why it works:
| Collaboration Type | Resource Savings | Implementation Timeline | Key Success Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shared Marketing | 40-60% cost reduction | 90 days | Branding consistency agreement |
| Joint Recruitment | Larger prospect pool | 6+ months | Clear lead-sharing protocol |
| Bulk Training | 30% lower per-person cost | 120 days | Standardized certification |
| Data Sharing | Eliminates duplicate research | Immediate | Secure cloud platform |
Warning: These require ironclad MOUs. We spent 4 months negotiating data ownership rights alone.
The day we stopped seeing neighboring towns as competitors? Game changer for grant applications.
Future-Proofing Your Economic Improvement Council
Economic shifts accelerate. Here's how we stay relevant:
- Scenario Planning - Annual "what if" workshops (automation impacts, climate risks)
- Young Professional Seats - Mandated 30% board members under 40
- Technology Scan - Quarterly review of emerging tools (last year: AI permit processing)
- Exit Strategies - Sunset plan for every initiative from day one
Remember: The economic improvement council model must evolve or become obsolete. We killed three legacy programs last year despite emotional attachments.
How do we demonstrate ROI to skeptical taxpayers?
Convert everything to household impact. Example: "Our workforce program placed 140 people in $50k+ jobs - boosting local spending by $3.7M annually."
What if key businesses oppose the council?
Happened to us. We invited critics to lead a task force addressing their concerns. Turned opponents into advocates.
Are there economic improvement council accreditation programs?
IEDC certification exists but costs $15k+. We prioritized local results over plaques.
Final thought? Economic improvement councils aren't silver bullets. But done right - with grit, data, and relentless focus - they're the best shot struggling communities have. When Main Street businesses start thriving again, you'll know it was worth the fight.
Leave a Comments