So you're digging into who was crucified with Jesus? Honestly, I used to skim past those two figures too. They seemed like footnotes until I stood at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem last year, staring at the spot traditionally marked as Golgotha. It hit me – these men shared Jesus' final agony yet get maybe 1% of the attention. Let's fix that.
The Crucifixion Scene: Setting the Stage
Picture Jerusalem around 30-33 AD during Passover. Crowds are packed into the city. Roman soldiers are everywhere, keeping order in this powder keg. Jesus, convicted of sedition, carries his cross through packed streets to Golgotha (meaning "Place of the Skull"). The air smells like dust and sweat. People shout – some wail, others jeer.
Now, crucifixion wasn't unusual. Rome used it constantly to terrify rebels and criminals. But this execution had three crosses. Jesus in the center, flanked by two others. Who were they? The Gospels call them "lestai" – a Greek word meaning bandits or revolutionaries. Not petty thieves. Think armed insurgents fighting Roman occupation.
Fun fact: The traditional crosses at churches show Jesus higher than the other two. But archaeology suggests all three were level. The Romans wouldn't elevate a condemned prisoner. They wanted equality in humiliation.
What We Know About the Two Men
Scripture gives sparse details, but we can reconstruct their profiles:
| Name/Designation | Traditional Role | Biblical Actions | Historical Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Unrepentant Criminal (Left Cross) | Mocked Jesus (Luke 23:39) | "Aren't you the Messiah? Save yourself and us!" | Probably a Zealot or nationalist fighter |
| The Penitent Thief (Right Cross) | Defended Jesus (Luke 23:40-41) | "Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom" | May have been coerced into rebellion |
Their dialogue speaks volumes. Crucifixion could last days. Pain was unimaginable. Yet amid suffocating agony, they argue theology! The unrepentant thief sees only political failure. The other recognizes spiritual authority. Wild, right?
Deep Dive: The Forgotten Figures
Let's break down what makes these men fascinating beyond being "the guys crucified with Jesus":
The Penitent Thief (Dismas)
Church tradition names him Dismas. His story resonates because he grasps Jesus' identity when even disciples fled. His request isn't for rescue but remembrance. Jesus' reply? "Today you will be with me in paradise" (Luke 23:43).
What fascinates me: Dismas defends Jesus while dying beside him. He admits his guilt ("We are punished justly") yet sees innocence in Jesus. That moral clarity in agony stuns me. Some scholars think he knew of Jesus' ministry beforehand. Maybe he'd heard Sermon on the Mount rumors. We'll never know.
The Unrepentant Thief (Gestas)
Traditionally called Gestas. His mocking reveals brutal pragmatism. If Jesus is Messiah, prove it by saving us! No faith – just demand. He represents every skeptic who says, "Fix my problems now, then I'll believe."
Historically, he fit the rebel profile. Jewish historian Josephus describes crucifixions of "bandits" during Passover riots. These weren't Robin Hood types. They murdered collaborators. Yet even Gestas dies beside grace incarnate and rejects it. Tragic.
Archaeological Insights: Crucifixion Practices
In 1968, archaeologists found a crucified man's heel bone in Jerusalem with a nail still embedded. Analysis revealed:
- Victims were nailed through wrists (not palms – flesh tears) and feet
- Death came from asphyxiation or shock; breaking legs sped it up (John 19:31-33)
- Bodies were usually left to rot or dumped in mass graves
Remarkably, Jesus and the two thieves got burial (John 19:38). Rare for crucifixion victims. Shows Joseph of Arimathea's influence.
Theological Significance: Why These Two Matter
The thieves illustrate humanity's split response to Jesus. One rejects, one accepts. Their positioning is symbolic too:
| Position Relative to Jesus | Theological Meaning | Artistic Depiction |
|---|---|---|
| Right side (Dismas) | Place of honor; "sheep at the right hand" (Matthew 25:33) | Often shown with brighter colors in icons |
| Left side (Gestas) | Place of condemnation; "goats at the left" (Matthew 25:33) | Dark, shadowed figures in medieval art |
Dismas' last-minute redemption comforts many. It shows salvation isn't earned by lifelong piety but by faith. Even at death's door. Honestly, that bothered me as a kid. "He lived violently but repented in five minutes?" But the parable of the workers (Matthew 20:1-16) addresses this: God's grace isn't fair by human standards.
Frequently Asked Questions
Were the men crucified with Jesus both thieves?
Yes, but "thief" is misleading. The Greek word "lestes" implies armed insurrection, not shoplifting. They were likely anti-Roman rebels.
Did the thieves deserve crucifixion?
By Roman law, yes. Crucifixion was for slaves, rebels, and traitors. But Jesus was innocent of the charges against him.
Why did one thief repent and not the other?
Scripture doesn't say. Perhaps Gestas was hardened by hatred. Dismas may have heard Jesus preach or witnessed his character during trials.
What happened to their bodies after death?
Likely given to families or buried by Jewish custom since the Sabbath approached (Deuteronomy 21:23). Romans sometimes permitted this during festivals.
Are there relics of these two men?
No credible relics exist. Medieval churches claimed various artifacts, but these lack historical basis.
Cultural Impact: From Art to Film
Ever noticed how films portray the two thieves? Mel Gibson's The Passion shows Gestas as snarling, Dismas as thoughtful. In literature, Dostoevsky referenced them in The Brothers Karamazov. Eastern Orthodox churches venerate St. Dismas – his feast day is March 25.
Interesting sidebar: In Renaissance art, Dismas often appears with a faint halo. Gestas? Twisted in agony. These portrayals cemented their symbolic roles.
Modern Parallels: What Their Stories Teach Today
Why care about two criminals executed 2,000 years ago? Because their choices mirror ours. Faced with Jesus, we either mock or embrace. Gestas demanded signs; Dismas trusted without evidence. I find myself asking: Which thief am I today?
Their inclusion in the crucifixion narrative shows nobody is beyond redemption. Not a dying rebel. Not you. Not me. That's why the story sticks.
Final thought: We remember emperors and kings from that era. Yet these two nameless rebels share eternity with the Savior they hung beside. History's ultimate irony.
Leave a Comments