Let's cut to the chase - when you're dealing with VA TDIU claims, that approval rate number feels like everything. I remember talking to my buddy Joe last year when he was applying. He kept asking me: "What are my actual chances here?" Honestly, the VA doesn't make this easy to figure out. After helping dozens of vets navigate this maze, here's what I've learned about how TDIU approval works in the real world.
TDIU stands for Total Disability based on Individual Unemployability. It's for veterans who can't hold down steady work because of service-connected disabilities, even if their combined disability rating isn't technically 100%.
Breaking Down VA TDIU Approval Rate Statistics
First off, let's get real about numbers. The VA doesn't publish an official VA TDIU approval rate dashboard - which is frustrating as hell. But through FOIA requests and case studies, we've pieced together a picture.
Year | Estimated Approval Rate | Major Influencing Factors |
---|---|---|
2023 | 35-40% | COVID backlog clearing, more virtual exams |
2022 | 31-36% | Staff shortages, paperwork delays |
2021 | 30-34% | Pandemic disruptions, limited C&P exams |
Look, these numbers might seem discouraging. But here's what they don't show - vets with complete applications and medical evidence often see approval rates above 60%. The system's messy, no doubt. Last month I saw a guy get denied because his psychiatrist wrote "patient has trouble working" instead of "patient CANNOT work". One word makes all the difference.
Regional Approval Rate Differences That Matter
Where you file impacts your VA TDIU approval rate chances:
- West Coast offices: Average 42% approval (San Diego highest at 46%)
- Southern states: 35-38% approval (Atlanta lowest at 32%)
- Midwest offices: 37-41% approval
- Northeast offices: 39-43% approval (New York highest at 45%)
Weird right? I spoke to a rater in Detroit who said their office pushes denials when vocational questionnaires are missing. Meanwhile in Seattle, they'll sometimes develop the claim further instead of denying. Go figure.
What Actually Moves the Needle on Your Approval Odds
Forget generic advice. Here's precisely what changes VA TDIU approval rate outcomes:
MISTAKE I SEE CONSTANTLY: Veterans submit employment records showing they quit jobs "to spend time with family" instead of stating disability forced resignation. That one phrasing choice can sink your claim.
Medical Evidence Checklist That Works
Based on approved cases:
- Doctor's statement specifically saying "unable to maintain gainful employment"
- Treatment records showing failed work attempts (with dates!)
- Vocational expert report - costs $500-$800 but worth every penny
- Psychiatric evaluation linking symptoms to work limitations
- Medication logs showing side effects affecting job performance
Remember Sam, that Marine from Ohio I helped? His PTSD rating was only 70%. But his psych doc included three sentences about how hypervigilance made him walk off a construction job. That note alone got him approved.
Employment Paperwork That Makes Raters Pay Attention
Document Type | Approval Boost | Where to Get It |
---|---|---|
Employer letters | High | Former supervisors (not HR!) |
Tax returns showing income drop | Medium | IRS transcripts |
SSDI denial specifically citing VA disabilities | Very High | Social Security Administration |
Pro tip: If you're under 55, grab a vocational assessment. Raters scrutinize younger vets harder about employability. Yeah, it's unfair - but knowing that helps you prepare.
Appeals Process Real Talk
Got denied? Join the club - happens to most of us. Here's how approval rates shift on appeal:
Appeal Stage | Avg. Success Rate | Timeframe | Cost Considerations |
---|---|---|---|
Supplemental Claim | 28% | 4-9 months | $0 (DIY possible) |
Higher-Level Review | 35% | 3-5 months | $0 |
BVA Hearing | 42% | 18-36 months | Attorney fees if won (20-33% of backpay) |
My take? If you've got strong evidence, Higher-Level Review punches above its weight. But if your medical file's thin, go supplemental and add new evidence. Saw a Navy vet last year wait two years for BVA only to get denied because he didn't submit new docs during the wait. Gut punch.
Why Some Veterans Win Appeals Against the Odds
- They submit updated treatment records EVERY 90 days during appeal
- Get coworkers (not friends) to write lay statements about work failures
- Highlight VA's duty to assist errors in denial letter
- Request an in-person hearing - raters see you struggle to sit through it
Funny story - a Vietnam vet I know brought his oxygen tank to his hearing. When he struggled to answer questions between breaths, the judge approved him before he left the building. Sometimes showing up is half the battle.
VA TDIU Approval Rate FAQs Veterans Actually Ask
Does age really affect VA TDIU approval rate?
Hell yes it does. Raters expect 55-year-olds to have less job options than 30-year-olds. Here's how it breaks down:
- Under 50: Approval odds increase 15% with vocational report
- 50-59: Strongest demographic if medical evidence exists
- 60+: Sometimes harder if VA argues you're "retired"
How much does a lawyer improve VA TDIU approval rate?
For initial claims? Maybe 5-10% if they catch evidence gaps. But for appeals? Night and day difference. Good attorneys know:
- Which vocational experts impress VA raters
- How to frame marginal employment (like sporadic Uber driving)
- The magic language to use in psychiatric DBQs
Worth their fees? Only if you're denied initially. Most take 20-33% of backpay but $0 upfront.
Do certain disabilities get higher VA TDIU approval rates?
Absolutely. Mental health claims (especially PTSD) dominate approvals. Why? Symptoms like panic attacks and mood swings are visibly incompatible with work. But here's the catch - the VA fights harder on these. You need:
- Detailed symptom logs showing work impacts
- Proof of medication adjustments during employment
- Therapist notes documenting failed coping strategies
Can you work at all with TDIU?
Technically yes, but it's a minefield. The "marginal employment" threshold changes annually ($14,580 in 2024). Problem is, I've seen vets get flagged for:
- Occasional freelance work (even $200/month)
- Family business "volunteering" that looks like employment
- Online surveys earning Amazon gift cards
My advice? Assume any income could trigger review. Document EVERY dollar as "sheltered" or "below poverty threshold."
Your Action Plan Based on Approval Data
Cutting through the VA fog, here's what moves VA TDIU approval rate odds in your favor:
Timeline | Critical Action | Impact on Approval |
---|---|---|
Day 1 | Request C-file to see what VA already knows | High (avoids evidence gaps) |
Month 1 | Get vocational assessment + employer letters | Very High |
C&P Exam | Bring bullet-point symptom/work impact list | Critical |
After filing | Upload new medical records every 60 days | Medium-High |
Final thought: The VA TDIU approval rate game isn't about luck. It's about proving you checked every box before the rater even looks at your file. Miss one item? They'll deny you just to clear their desk. But when you make your claim airtight - when your evidence slaps them in the face with the truth - that approval letter feels like justice.
Still stressed? Join a vet-specific TDIU Facebook group. Seriously. Those guys share denial letters and approval forms like trading cards. You'll learn more in a week than reading VA handbooks all month.
Leave a Comments