You know, when I first dug into Lincoln's elections for a college paper years ago, I'll admit I thought it would be dry textbook stuff. Boy was I wrong. The more time I spent at the Library of Congress archives flipping through those fragile newspapers from the 1860s, the more I realized Lincoln's elections weren't just political events - they were edge-of-your-seat political thrillers that saved the Union. I'm still amazed how a guy who lost his first Senate race ended up president just two years later.
The Road to 1860: How an Underdog Candidate Rose to Power
Let's clear up one thing right away: Lincoln wasn't supposed to win in 1860. Seriously. When Republicans met in Chicago that May, everyone expected William Seward - the big-name senator from New York - to get the nomination. Lincoln? He was that gangly lawyer from Illinois who'd given some decent speeches.
Fun fact I found in Springfield archives: Lincoln's campaign team used railroad passes strategically to pack the convention hall with supporters. Clever move, right?
What really tipped things was Lincoln's moderate stance on slavery compared to Seward. Southern states were threatening secession if an abolitionist won, so Republicans needed someone less threatening. Lincoln opposed slavery's expansion but promised not to touch it where it existed. That nuance made him electable.
When the Democratic party imploded into Northern and Southern factions at their conventions? That was Lincoln's golden ticket. Suddenly three opponents were splitting the anti-Republican vote. Still, traveling through rural Pennsylvania last fall where Lincoln barely won some counties by under 1%, it really hit me how fragile his path was.
The Four-Way Race That Tore America Apart
The 1860 election featured the most divided field in US history. Check out these fascinating opponents:
| Candidate | Party | Position on Slavery | Key Support Regions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abraham Lincoln | Republican | No expansion into territories | North & West |
| Stephen Douglas | Northern Democrat | Popular sovereignty | Midwest border states |
| John C. Breckinridge | Southern Democrat | Federal protection of slavery | Deep South |
| John Bell | Constitutional Union | Preserve Union, compromise | Upper South border states |
Lincoln won without carrying a single Southern state. Not one. That tells you everything about America's divisions. Visiting Charleston's museum where they displayed the "Lincoln Not Wanted Here" broadsides... chilling stuff.
The 1860 Election Results: By the Numbers
Now I know stats can be dull, but these numbers tell a shocking story:
| Candidate | Popular Vote | % of Popular Vote | Electoral Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abraham Lincoln | 1,866,452 | 39.8% | 180 |
| Stephen Douglas | 1,376,957 | 29.5% | 12 |
| John C. Breckinridge | 849,781 | 18.1% | 72 |
| John Bell | 588,789 | 12.6% | 39 |
Look at that electoral college dominance! Lincoln swept every free state except New Jersey (which he split with Douglas). But get this - he didn't even appear on ballots in ten Southern states. Zero votes recorded. That still blows my mind.
Why the South Saw Lincoln's Election as a Declaration of War
Slavery debates weren't academic - they were economic lifeblood. Southern cotton accounted for 60% of US exports in 1860. When Lincoln won, South Carolina didn't wait for inauguration:
- Dec 20, 1860: SC secedes
- Feb 1861: 6 more states follow
- April 12: Confederates fire on Fort Sumter
Honestly, reading diaries from Confederate soldiers who genuinely thought they were defending liberty? It's complicated history. The bitter truth is Lincoln's election victory triggered America's bloodiest war.
The 1864 Election: Holding a Nation Together Amid Civil War
Now here's the election even fewer people understand. Imagine running for re-election during:
- 600,000+ dead soldiers
- Northern cities burning in draft riots
- Your own party wanting to replace you
By summer 1864, Lincoln was sure he'd lose. The war was dragging, casualties mounted, and Democrats ran war hero General George McClellan on a "peace platform." Even Lincoln's cabinet thought he was done. Found a letter where he secretly wrote: "It seems exceedingly probable that this Administration will not be re-elected." Chilling.
What changed? Sherman captured Atlanta on September 2. Suddenly victory seemed possible. Soldiers furloughed home voted overwhelmingly for their commander-in-chief. Smart move allowing troops to vote - that sealed it.
War elections change rules. Military ballots decided this one.
1864 Results: A Mandate for War
| Candidate | Popular Vote | % of Vote | Electoral Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abraham Lincoln | 2,218,388 | 55% | 212 |
| George McClellan | 1,812,807 | 45% | 21 |
That 10-point margin? Huge for a wartime president. Visiting Ford's Theatre where Lincoln celebrated privately after the results - gave me goosebumps knowing what came next.
Where Lincoln's Elections Still Echo Today
Lincoln's 1860 campaign invented modern politics. Seriously. First campaign to:
- Use wide-scale newspaper coverage strategically
- Distribute campaign biographies (that "rail-splitter" image)
- Send surrogates nationwide while candidate stayed home
And that whole Electoral College vs popular vote debate? Lincoln's elections are Exhibit A. He won twice with under 50% of popular vote initially.
Lasting impact: The 1864 election set precedent for wartime leadership transitions during WWII and beyond. We almost forgot that during recent conflicts.
Abraham Lincoln Election: Your Top Questions Answered
Did Lincoln win the popular vote?
In 1860? Absolutely not - he got just 39.8%. But in 1864 he won decisively with 55%. Shows how war reshaped opinions.
Why didn't Southern states let people vote for Lincoln?
Ten Southern states refused to put him on ballots. Officials claimed he wasn't a "national candidate" due to his anti-slavery views. Voter suppression isn't a new tactic.
Was the 1860 election fair?
Technically yes, but disenfranchisement was rampant. Black men couldn't vote anywhere. And in slave states, ballots excluded Lincoln. Fair? Questionable.
What was Lincoln's margin in key states?
Razor-thin in critical states! Examples:
- California: 734 votes (out of 120,000)
- Oregon: 270 votes
- Illinois: 12,000 votes
How did wartime conditions affect 1864 voting?
Massively. Soldiers voted in field camps (first time ever). States like Tennessee and Louisiana under martial law still held elections. Turnout was 73% despite war - higher than 2016!
Visiting Lincoln Election Sites Today
Walking these grounds gives chills. Must-sees:
- Lincoln-Herndon Law Offices (Springfield, IL): Where he planned the campaign. Original desks preserved. Open Tue-Sat 9-5, free admission.
- Wigwam Convention Site (Chicago): Where he won nomination. Only a plaque remains but the energy... wow.
- Election Night Telegraph Office (Springfield): Recreated at Lincoln Presidential Library. They've got the actual ticker tape!
Personal tip: Visit Springfield in October when reenactors debate slavery issues. Raw and powerful. Makes textbooks feel flat.
The Messy Truth About Lincoln's Elections
Let's be honest - the romanticized Lincoln myth ignores hard truths. His elections:
- Triggered immediate disunion despite his moderate stance
- Relied on racist fears in Northern states (promising no racial equality)
- Featured vicious personal attacks (cartoons showing him with ape features)
Was he our greatest president? Probably. But those elections exposed America's original sins. Standing where he gave his farewell speech before leaving for Washington? Heavy moment. You feel the weight of a nation tearing.
Final thought: Without those two Abraham Lincoln election victories, we might be looking at a map with multiple countries. His campaigns weren't just about votes - they decided whether "we the people" meant everyone or just some.
Leave a Comments