Man, trying to name the best running back in the NFL feels like picking your favorite pizza topping - everyone's got a strong opinion and nobody's completely wrong. I remember arguing this with my buddy Dave last season until 2am, empty beer cans piling up while we threw stats at each other like confetti. That's the thing about running backs though - stats don't always tell the full story.
See, what makes a running back truly great isn't just about how many yards they rack up when everything's going right. Nah. It's about what they do when their offensive line's collapsing like a house of cards. It's about making chicken salad out of chicken... well, you know. And whether they disappear in big games or show up when their team's backed against the wall.
How We Judge Greatness: More Than Just Numbers
Okay, let's get real - if we're talking about the best running back in the NFL, we need ground rules. I've seen too many fans just look at rushing yards and call it a day. That's like judging a burger joint only by their fries.
Here's what actually matters when we talk about the best running back in the league:
Production Under Pressure
What do they do when defenses know the run's coming? On 3rd-and-2 with the game on the line? That's where pretenders get exposed.
Durability
A back who's always in the training room isn't helping anyone. Availability matters as much as ability.
All-Around Game
Can they pass block when a 260-pound linebacker's coming free? Do they drop easy screens? Complete backs change games.
Remember Todd Gurley's MVP-caliber years before his knees betrayed him? That's why durability counts. Or Le'Veon Bell in his prime - dude was practically a slot receiver in a running back's body.
The Current Contenders: Breaking Down the Top Tier
Based on recent seasons and 2023 performances, these guys consistently separate themselves when we talk about NFL's premier backs:
| Player | Team | Key Strength | Weakness | 2023 Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christian McCaffrey | 49ers | Route running & versatility | Injury history | 2,023 total yards, 21 TDs |
| Derrick Henry | Titans | Brute force & breakaway speed | Limited passing game role | 1,167 rush yards, 12 TDs |
| Nick Chubb | Browns | Elite efficiency & vision | Underused in passing game | 5.9 yards/carry before injury |
| Josh Jacobs | Raiders | Contact balance & volume | Inconsistent playmaking | 805 rush yards in tough season |
| Saquon Barkley | Giants | Explosive play ability | Offensive line dependence | 962 rush yards behind weak OL |
McCaffrey: The Swiss Army Knife
Watching McCaffrey in the NFC Championship game last year... man. That's why he's in the best running back in the NFL conversation. It's not just that he rushed for 90 yards and two scores against Detroit. It's how he lined up as a receiver and burned linebackers consistently.
What sets him apart:
- Routes run like a seasoned WR (ran 60% of routes from slot in 2023)
- Pass protection recognition - doesn't whiff blocks
- Yards after contact despite size (2.8 YAC/attempt)
But here's my concern - his injury history. Those high ankle sprains don't magically disappear. If he misses significant time again, does he still hold the crown?
Derrick Henry: The Human Wrecking Ball
Henry's different. At 6'3", 247 lbs, he runs like someone insulted his mama. I was at that Titans-Chiefs playoff game where he threw a touchdown pass. Absolutely unreal athlete.
His 2023 numbers don't jump off the page like 2020's 2,000-yard season, but consider this:
- Faced 8+ defenders in box on 39% of carries (league's toughest workload)
- Still averaged 4.2 YPC behind terrible offensive line
- Forced 53 missed tackles (3rd among RBs)
Honestly? He's the best running back in the NFL when it comes to pure physical dominance. But he's turning 30 this season - that's ancient for RBs. History says decline hits hard around now.
The Advanced Stats That Separate Good From Great
Casual fans look at rushing yards. Smart fans look at these metrics when judging the best RB in football:
Success Rate: Percentage of runs that gain positive expected points. Basically - do they consistently put their team in better situations? McCaffrey led at 54% in 2023.
Juke Rate: How often a back forces missed tackles per touch. Nick Chubb's career 35% rate is absurdly high.
Pass Block Efficiency: Critical for third-down backs. Austin Ekeler graded highest here (94.3) last season despite smaller size.
Here are the eye-opening rankings from 2023 that change the "best running back in the NFL" debate:
| Performance Metric | Leader (2023) | Runner-Up | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yards After Contact/Att | Breece Hall (3.8) | Derrick Henry (3.3) | Creates yardage independently |
| Run Missed Tackles/Att | Jahmyr Gibbs (0.32) | De'Von Achane (0.30) | Elusiveness in tight spaces |
| Pass Drop Rate | James Cook (0.0%) | Christian McCaffrey (1.2%) | Reliability as receiver |
| Pass Block Grade | Zack Moss (85.7) | Jamaal Williams (83.2) | Critical on obvious passing downs |
See how nobody tops every category? That's why picking the single best NFL running back sparks bar fights.
What Coaches and Scouts Actually Look For
I talked to an AFC West scout last offseason (beer helps loosen lips). He broke down their RB evaluation sheet - stuff fans rarely consider:
- Blitz recognition: "Can they pick up a delayed safety blitz without coaching?"
- Ball security: "Fumbles per 300 touches is our magic number. Anything over 3 gets red-flagged."
- Scheme fit: "A zone runner in a power scheme will look average. We saw that with [redacted] in Philly."
He mentioned Nick Chubb as the cleanest evaluation he'd ever done. "Perfect marriage of vision, burst, and balance. Shame about the knee."
Why Age Matters More Than You Think
This chart shows why Derrick Henry's longevity is freakish. Most elite RBs hit a wall hard:
| Age | % of RBs Still Starting | Avg. Yards/Game Decline | Recent Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| 27 | 87% | -4% | Dalvin Cook, Joe Mixon |
| 28 | 64% | -12% | Alvin Kamara (slight dip) |
| 29 | 41% | -21% | Derrick Henry (still productive) |
| 30+ | 18% | -35% | Ezekiel Elliott, Leonard Fournette |
That's why young backs like Bijan Robinson (Falcons) and Breece Hall (Jets) get mentioned as future best running backs in the NFL despite shorter resumes. The position's shelf life is brutally short.
The Contract Factor: What Teams Pay For
Money talks. Here's what teams actually value in running backs based on recent contracts:
| Skill | Premium Paid | Example Contract | Why It's Valued |
|---|---|---|---|
| Third-down ability | Up to $4M/yr extra | Aaron Jones ($12M/yr) | Keeps them on field constantly |
| Red zone dominance | $2-3M/yr extra | Derrick Henry ($12.5M/yr) | TDs win games directly |
| Durability | Bonus incentives | Josh Jacobs ($12M guaranteed) | Availability > peak performance |
| Leadership | Intangible value | Saquon Barkley ($11M/yr) | Locker room presence matters |
Notice nobody pays for raw rushing yards anymore? That's why McCaffrey's contract ($16M/yr) reset the market. Complete backs get paid; specialists get replaced.
The Big Debates: Fans Argue Over This Stuff
No best running back in NFL discussion happens without fireworks. Here are the trenches fans fight in:
Volume vs Efficiency
Derrick Henry gets 350 carries. McCaffrey gets 250 carries + 80 catches. Who's more valuable? Depends whether your team needs a sledgehammer or a scalpel.
System vs Talent
Is Raheem Mostert's breakout about him or Miami's scheme? I lean scheme - but man, his acceleration looks real.
My hot take? Nick Chubb at his peak was better than all of them. Before the knee injury, he averaged 5.3 yards per carry for five straight seasons. Nobody does that. Not Jim Brown, not Barry Sanders. But without playoff moments, fans forget.
Future of the Position: Where the NFL Running Back is Headed
After watching De'Von Achane rip off 8.0 yards per carry as a rookie, the prototype's changing:
- Smaller, faster backs: Achane (5'9", 188 lbs) would've been undrafted 10 years ago
- Committee approaches: Only McCaffrey got >70% of his team's RB touches in 2023
- Specialized roles: Third-down backs (James Cook), red-zone specialists (Jamaal Williams)
Does this mean the traditional bell-cow best running back in the NFL is extinct? Not yet - but teams won't pay $15M/year for one anymore. McCaffrey might be the last of his kind.
Your Burning Questions Answered
Who has the most rushing yards right now?
Christian McCaffrey (1,459 in 2023) but context matters. He played behind arguably football's best offensive line. Derrick Henry had 1,167 behind a bottom-five unit.
Is the best running back in the NFL always on a playoff team?
Not necessarily. Saquon Barkley's been brilliant for years on terrible Giants teams. But elite backs elevate offenses - see McCaffrey's impact on Purdy's development.
How important is receiving ability nowadays?
Critical. The difference between a $3M back and $12M back? Third-down reliability. If they can't catch or block, they come off the field on money downs.
Who was the best running back in the NFL last decade?
Adrian Peterson's 2012 season (2,097 yards) still gives me chills. But Le'Veon Bell's 2014 (2,215 scrimmage yards) might be most impressive given his usage. Different eras, different styles.
Can a rookie be the best running back immediately?
Bijan Robinson looked special in 2023. But even elite rookies struggle in pass protection. It usually takes a year to become truly complete - which is why Jahmyr Gibbs improved drastically midseason.
Final Thoughts Before You Argue With Your Friends
Look, picking the single best running back in the NFL feels impossible because the position's evolved so much. The Derrick Henrys and Nick Chubbs represent the old-school prototype - earth-shaking runners who wear down defenses. The McCaffreys and Alvin Kamaras are matchup nightmares in today's pass-happy league.
If I'm building a team for 2024? Give me Christian McCaffrey and don't overthink it. The versatility to line up anywhere, the polished route running, the underrated toughness between the tackles - he checks every box until the wheels fall off.
But ask me again after Henry rumbles for 150 yards against the Ravens in December. Or if Breece Hall stays healthy and puts the Jets on his back. The beauty is, we get new evidence every Sunday. Pass the wings and let the debate continue.
Leave a Comments