So you're thinking about grabbing Persona 3 Reload? Smart move. But you're also digging through dozens of Persona 3 Reload reviews trying to figure if it's worth your cash. I get it - I was in that exact spot last month. Having sunk 90+ hours into both the original and this remake, let me break it down for you straight.
Wait, What Even is Persona 3 Reload?
For newcomers: Persona 3 Reload ($59.99 on Steam/PS5/Xbox, $69.99 for deluxe edition) is Atlus's ground-up remake of their 2006 cult classic JRPG. Imagine high school by day, fighting demons in a creepy tower by night, mixed with life-sim stuff like making friends and joining clubs. Weird combo? Absolutely. But it works.
Real Talk: I nearly skipped this because I played the original. Glad I didn't. The visual overhaul alone makes every rainy evening in Iwatodai feel new. But we'll get to that.
The Good Stuff: Why People Are Obsessed
Visuals That Actually Matter
Remember those PS2-era chibi models? Gone. Character models now look like Persona 5 quality - sharp, expressive, with killer UI transitions. Tartarus (that demon tower) got the biggest glow-up. Each block has unique textures now instead of copy-pasted hallways. Small thing? Maybe. But at 2 AM when you're grinding, it keeps you sane.
Combat That Doesn't Put You to Sleep
They kept the turn-based roots but added:
- Theurgy system: Special character-specific super moves (like Yukari's healing nuke)
- Shift mechanic: Think Baton Pass from P5 but smoother
- Actual AI control: No more Mitsuru wasting turns on Marin Karin!
Battles feel 30% faster. When you're fighting the same Shadow for the tenth time? Blessing.
| Combat Feature | Original P3 | P3 Reload | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Party Control | AI only (except PSP version) | Full manual control | No more rage-quitting over dumb AI choices |
| Shift/Baton Pass | ✗ Absent | ✓ Added | Keeps combat flow dynamic |
| Skill Inheritance | Random | Pick your skills | Actually build Personas you want |
Quality of Life Upgrades You'll Cheer For
- Fast travel: Jump between locations instantly. No more running through entire school corridors.
- Tartarus save points: Save anywhere on floors (not just teleporters). Lifesaver.
- Boosted Social Links: New dialogue options and scenes (especially for male SEES members)
My personal favorite? Being able to study in your room at night for courage points. No more grinding bookstore jobs.
The Not-So-Great: What Reviews Don't Say Enough
Look, I love this game. But after three playthroughs, here's what grinds my gears:
- Still no FemMC: If you played Portable, you'll miss her unique story routes.
- The Answer is missing: That FES epilogue chapter? Not included. Might be DLC later ($?) but right now? Gone.
- Some social links feel dated: Tanaka's shady salesman bit hits different in 2024.
"I cried at the ending... again. Even knowing what was coming, the new voice acting wrecked me." - My 3 AM text to a friend after finishing
How Does It Stack Up? Reload vs Older Versions
Let's settle this once and for all:
| Version | Platform | Key Advantages | Biggest Drawbacks | Who Should Play This? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Persona 3 FES (2007) | PS2/Emulation | Includes "The Answer" epilogue, cheaper | Dated graphics, no party control | Purists who want EVERYTHING |
| Persona 3 Portable (2009) | PSP/Modern Remasters | Female protagonist option, faster pacing | Visual novel style, no 3D exploration | Those valuing story choice portability |
| Persona 3 Reload (2024) | PS5/Xbox/PC | Modern visuals/QoL, voice acting, combat depth | Missing "The Answer", no female route | New players & fans wanting premium experience |
Honestly? If this is your first Persona 3 rodeo, Reload is the way to go. The missing content hurts, but the polish elsewhere more than compensates.
Critical Reception: What Other Persona 3 Reload Reviews Say
Aggregated scores tell a clear story:
- Metacritic: (PS5)
- Opencritic:
- User Scores: Mostly 4.5/5 stars
Common praises across IGN, GameSpot, and niche blogs:
- "The definitive way to experience P3's story" - RPG Site
- "Combat upgrades modernize without losing soul" - Polygon
- "Voice acting elevates emotional moments" - Siliconera
But criticisms pop up too:
- "Tartarus still repetitive despite visual upgrades" - Eurogamer
- "Missing content hard to ignore for veterans" - Destructoid
Buyer's Guide: Should YOU Get Persona 3 Reload?
Worth Every Penny If...
- You never played any version of P3
- You bounced off older versions due to jank
- You love story-rich JRPGs like Persona 5
- Modern QoL features are non-negotiable
Maybe Wait For Sale If...
- You recently played FES/Portable
- The missing FemMC route is a dealbreaker
- You demand every scrap of canon content
Physical copies hover around $49.99 new (check Amazon/Walmart), while digital stays at $59.99. The $69.99 deluxe edition gets you digital artbook and soundtrack. Worth it for OST fans - that remixed Mass Destruction track? Chef's kiss.
Persona 3 Reload Reviews FAQ: Quickfire Questions
Is this a remake or remaster?
Full remake. Built from scratch in Unreal Engine. Not just a texture pack.
How long to beat?
Main story: 60-70 hours. Completionist runs? 100+. My first playthrough took 83 hours doing most social links.
Performance issues?
PS5/Xbox Series X: Solid 60fps. PC? Demanding on older GPUs - tweak settings if you lack a RTX 3060/equivalent.
Do I need to play other Persona games?
Nope. Standalone story. Though Persona 5 fans will spot gameplay similarities.
Is the ending changed?
No major story changes. Same tearjerker conclusion, just with incredible new voice work.
How's the music?
Lotus Juice and Azumi Takahashi return. New arrangements slap - "Color Your Night" might replace "Beneath the Mask" as your study jam.
The Final Verdict After 90 Hours
Persona 3 Reload isn't perfect. The missing content stings, and Tartarus still tests your patience. But hot damn - it transforms a dated PS2 gem into a modern masterpiece. The combat tweaks, visual overhaul, and voice acting don't just refresh the game; they amplify its emotional gut punches.
If you're hunting through Persona 3 Reload reviews wondering if it holds up... yeah. It does. For veterans, it's like reuniting with old friends in HD. For newcomers? This is the golden ticket into one of gaming's most profound stories about life, death, and finding meaning in the darkness.
Just maybe keep tissues handy for December.
Leave a Comments