So you just got your shiny new PS5 and you're wondering about those extra DualShock 4 controllers collecting dust. I had the exact same thought when I upgraded. Turns out, the answer isn't a simple yes or no – it's complicated. Let me break it down based on my own experience and what actually works.
The Official Word from Sony
Sony's stance is surprisingly straightforward: Yes, you can connect your PS4 controller to a PS5, but with major limitations. I remember feeling pretty annoyed when I first discovered these restrictions. Essentially:
Your DualShock 4 will work for playing PS4 games on your PS5, but it won't work for native PS5 games. That means if you're firing up Spider-Man: Miles Morales (the PS5 version), you'll need the DualSense controller.
Why This Feels Like a Step Back
Honestly, it's frustrating. My friend brought over his DualShock 4 when we wanted to play some multiplayer PS4 titles, but when we switched to the new Call of Duty on PS5, it was a no-go. Sony says it's because the DualSense has advanced features like haptic feedback and adaptive triggers that PS5 games require. Makes sense... but still annoying when you've got perfectly good controllers lying around.
When Your PS4 Controller Actually Works on PS5
Let's talk about what DOES work because that's where things get interesting. I've tested this extensively:
| Scenario | DualShock 4 Compatible? | Personal Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Playing PS4 games on PS5 | Yes | Works perfectly with my entire PS4 library |
| Playing PS5 games | No | Got that "incompatible" error immediately |
| Remote Play from PS5 to other devices | Yes | Used it on my iPad without issues |
| Navigating PS5 menus | Partial | Can browse but not launch PS5 games |
| Media apps (Netflix, YouTube) | Yes | Handy for couch navigation |
I've found it incredibly useful for PS4 titles – especially since I didn't want to rebuy games like Ghost of Tsushima. But trying to use it for Returnal? Forget it.
Hooking It Up: Step-by-Step Walkthrough
Connecting your controller isn't rocket science, but there are some quirks. Here's how I did it:
1 Grab a USB-C cable (same as phone chargers)
2 Plug it into your PS5 and DualShock 4
3 Press the PS button on the controller
4 Wait for the light bar to turn blue
For Bluetooth pairing (which I prefer):
- Go to Settings > Accessories > Bluetooth Accessories
- Hold SHARE + PS button until light bar flashes
- Select "Wireless Controller" on PS5
Took me about 90 seconds the first time. Much easier than when I tried pairing my third-party headset!
The Real Limitations You Need to Know
Before you get too excited about using your PS4 controller on PS5, here's what actually doesn't work:
Dealbreakers
- Zero compatibility with PS5 games
- No haptic feedback or adaptive triggers
- Mic won't work through controller
- Cannot turn on PS5 with DualShock 4
That last one bugs me the most. I keep my controllers on a charging dock, and it's annoying having to walk over to the console just to power it on.
Why Sony Made This Decision
After digging into developer interviews, it makes sense. PS5 games are built around the DualSense capabilities. Games like Astro's Playroom would lose their magic without those advanced features. Still, I wish they'd let us opt-out for games where it doesn't matter as much.
Smart Alternatives That Actually Work
If you're determined to use other controllers for PS5 games, here are options I've tested:
| Solution | PS5 Game Compatibility | Cost | My Experience |
|---|---|---|---|
| DualSense Edge | Full | $200 | Great but crazy expensive |
| Third-party PS5 controllers | Full | $60-$150 | Hit or miss quality |
| Controller converters | Partial | $20-$40 | Lag issues in fast games |
| Remote Play workaround | Full (with lag) | Free | Only for single-player games |
Honestly? The Remote Play trick is clever but frustratingly laggy unless you've got perfect Wi-Fi. I tried playing Horizon Forbidden West this way and kept missing shots.
Your Questions Answered (No Fluff)
Will PlayStation ever fix this?
Don't hold your breath. Sony's official support page still says DualShock 4 "is not compatible with PS5 games" as of early 2024. I've seen zero indication they'll change this.
Can I trick my PS5 into accepting DualShock 4?
Sort of. Special USB converters like Brook Wingman can fool the system, but they add input lag and cost about $40. Tried one for Fortnite and noticed slight delays in build battles.
What happens if I try to launch a PS5 game with DualShock 4?
You'll get error code WS-116332-6. Happened to me when my nephew grabbed the wrong controller. The message says "Can't use this controller to play the selected game."
Do PS4 controllers work for split-screen PS5 games?
Nope. Tested this with It Takes Two – only DualSense controllers worked for the PS5 version. Such a bummer for local multiplayer fans.
Making the Best of Your Situation
Here's how I manage my controller situation based on what you might be doing:
- PS4 game nights: Use DualShock 4 controllers exclusively
- PS5 gaming sessions: DualSense stays charged on dock
- Travel setup: Pack DualShock 4 for Remote Play on laptop
- Media center: Keep one DualShock 4 near TV for streaming
Honestly, the DualSense is an amazing controller once you get used to it. Those adaptive triggers in racing games genuinely change the experience. But I still miss the lighter weight of my old DualShock during long gaming sessions.
The Bottom Line
Can you use a PS4 controller on PS5? Technically yes, but practically only for half of what you'll want to do. If you're mainly playing PS4 titles or using Remote Play, those old controllers are golden. For native PS5 experiences though, you'll need to invest in Sony's new hardware. It's not ideal, but it's the reality we're stuck with for now.
What's your experience been? I'm still hunting for a reliable third-party option that doesn't cost a fortune – if you've found one, let me know!
Leave a Comments