So you're trying fasting - maybe for weight loss, maybe for health benefits, maybe for religious reasons. And suddenly you're staring at your water bottle wondering: "What else can I actually drink without wrecking this fast?" Trust me, I've been there. Last Ramadan, I accidentally broke my fast with a "zero-calorie" lemonade that secretly had artificial sweeteners. Rookie mistake.
Why Your Drink Choices Matter During Fasting
This isn't just about quenching thirst. What you drink during fasting windows affects:
- Whether you're actually staying in fasted state (autophagy benefits)
- Blood sugar stability (avoid those energy crashes)
- Electrolyte balance (hello, headache prevention)
- Hunger management (some drinks make you hungrier!)
Funny story - my first intermittent fasting attempt failed because I was drinking bone broth thinking it was "fasting-approved." Turns out that 50-calorie cup was spiking my insulin enough to knock me out of ketosis. Whoops.
The Absolute Non-Negotiables: Zero-Calorie Drinks
If it's got calories, it's probably breaking your fast. But here's what's safe:
Water: The Undisputed Champion
Plain water is always safe, but let's be real - it gets boring. Here's how to jazz it up:
| Water Type | Why It Works | My Personal Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Mineral water (Topo Chico, San Pellegrino) | Natural electrolytes, satisfies carbonation cravings | ★★★★★ (lifesaver!) |
| Infused water (lemon/cucumber slices) | Flavor without calories; use whole slices, not juice | ★★★☆☆ (gets old fast) |
| Filtered tap water with pinch of Himalayan salt | Prevents electrolyte imbalance during extended fasts | ★★★★☆ (tastes weird but works) |
Pro tip: Invest in a good bottle. My Hydro Flask ($35) keeps ice frozen for 24 hours - crucial for summer fasts.
Black Coffee: The Fasting Warrior
Good news coffee lovers! Black coffee is generally fasting-safe. But details matter:
- Brew type matters: Cold brew (Stok Unsweetened) is less acidic
- Bean quality: Cheap coffee = more stomach irritation
- Temperature: Iced coffee curbs appetite better for me
Warning: That "tiny splash of cream" breaks your fast! I tested this with blood glucose monitor - even 1 tbsp heavy cream spiked my levels.
Tea Choices That Won't Break Your Fast
Tea is tricky. Some herbal teas actually contain fruit solids with calories. Stick to these:
| Tea Type | Brand Recommendations | Special Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| Green tea (Sencha, Matcha) | Jade Leaf ceremonial grade ($29/30 servings) | Boosts metabolism, contains EGCG |
| Peppermint tea | Traditional Medicinals ($5/box) | Natural appetite suppressant |
| Rooibos | Numi Organic ($7/box) | Caffeine-free, mineral-rich |
Avoid "fruit-infused" teas like Tazo Passion - those hibiscus petals have calories!
The Gray Area Drinks (Proceed with Caution)
These are hotly debated in fasting communities. Here's my take after trial and error:
Apple Cider Vinegar: The Fasting Hack?
1 tbsp Bragg's ACV ($5/bottle) in water:
- Pros: Curbs cravings, may lower blood glucose
- Cons: Erodes tooth enamel (use straw!), tastes awful
- Verdict: Probably safe but not pleasant
Electrolyte Supplements: Necessary for Long Fasts?
For fasts over 24 hours, electrolytes become critical. Safe options:
| Product | Cost | Why It Works/Fails |
|---|---|---|
| LMNT unflavored ($45/30 packets) | $$$ | Zero sugar/calories, optimal sodium-magnesium ratio |
| Ultima Replenisher ($25/tub) | $$ | Stevia-sweetened - technically breaks fast for purists |
| DIY mix (salt + NoSalt potassium) | $ | Cheapest option, tastes like ocean water |
During my 72-hour fast, LMNT saved me from dizziness. Worth every penny.
What Definitely Breaks Your Fast
Don't sabotage yourself! These will knock you out of fasting state:
The Forbidden List
- Bone broth (sorry Paleo folks - 50 calories/cup)
- "Zero-calorie" sodas (Diet Coke spikes insulin in many people)
- Almond milk in coffee (even 30 calories matters)
- Lemon juice (1 tbsp = 4 calories + sugar)
- BCAAs (marketed for fasting but contain calories!)
Fun fact: I once tested different drinks with blood ketone monitor. Diet Coke dropped my ketones 30% in 20 minutes. Never again.
FAQs: Your Burning Questions Answered
Can I drink diet soda while fasting?
Technically zero calories, but artificial sweeteners (aspartame, sucralose) may:
- Trigger insulin response in sensitive people
- Increase cravings (personal experience - makes me ravenous!)
- Disrupt gut microbiome
If you absolutely must, Zevia (stevia-sweetened) is least bad option ($8/6-pack).
Is lemon water allowed during fasting?
Here's the deal:
- 1 lemon wedge in 32oz water: Probably fine (negligible calories)
- Squeezed lemon juice (1+ tbsp): Breaks fast
- Bottled lemon juice: Often contains preservatives/sugar - avoid!
I stick to lemon zest in water - flavor without juice.
What about sparkling water like LaCroix?
Most are safe BUT:
- Avoid "essenced" waters with juice concentrate (Hint has 2g sugar)
- Watch for citric acid - triggers hunger for some people
- Best options: Spindrift Unsweetened (real citrus oil, no juice)
Final Tip: Listen to Your Body
After coaching 100+ fasting clients, here's what I know:
- If a drink makes you hungry 30 mins later, ditch it
- Headaches during fast? Up your mineral water/salt intake
- Hunger pangs? Try hot peppermint tea first
Remember, what works for keto fasters might not work for Ramadan observers. Context matters. Personally, I rotate between Topo Chico, cold brew, and jasmine green tea - keeps things interesting without breaking my fast.
So next time you're wondering "what can I drink when fasting," stick to the basics. Your fasted state will thank you.
Leave a Comments