Self Employed Insurance Guide: Health, Liability & Disability for Freelancers (2023)

You finally did it. Quit the 9-to-5 grind, set up your own shop. Feels amazing, right? Until that first moment you realize: "Wait, who's gonna cover me if I slice my hand cooking dinner?" or "What if a client sues me over that website glitch?" That's when self employed insurance stops being boring paperwork and starts feeling like oxygen.

I learned this the hard way when I threw out my back installing shelves in my home office. Three weeks of zero income. Zero safety net. That wake-up call cost me way more than any insurance premium ever would.

Why Going Bare Is Playing With Fire

Let's cut through the jargon. When you work for yourself, self employed insurance isn't luxury padding – it's foundational. No HR department magically handles this stuff. I've seen too many consultants and freelancers think they'll "get to it later." Bad plan. One lawsuit or medical emergency can torch years of work.

Remember Sarah? Graphic designer I know. Client tripped over her laptop cord at a coffee shop meeting. Broken wrist. $42,000 medical bill plus lost wages claim. No general liability coverage. She's still paying that off two years later.

The Core Policies Freelancers Actually Need

Forget those generic lists telling you to buy everything. Based on fifteen years consulting with solopreneurs, here's what matters most:

Non-Negotiable Coverage

  • Health Insurance: Unless you enjoy $15,000 ER surprises
  • Professional Liability (E&O): Client sues over your work? This fights back
  • General Liability: Covers physical damage or injuries (like Sarah's disaster)
  • Disability Insurance: Your income stops if YOU break

Notice what's not on that list? Business property insurance can usually wait unless you've got $20k in camera gear. Workers comp? Only if you hire employees.

Health Insurance: Untangling the Mess

This is where most self-employed folks get headaches. Marketplace plans? Private insurers? Health sharing ministries? Let's break down real costs and traps.

Option Avg. Monthly Cost Best For Watch Out For
ACA Marketplace Plans $450-$850 Those qualifying for subsidies (income under $54k) Limited networks; annual enrollment windows
Private Health Insurance $500-$1,200+ People wanting broader doctor choices Medical underwriting can deny coverage
Health Sharing Plans $200-$500 Very healthy individuals on tight budgets Pre-existing conditions often excluded; not real insurance

Pro tip: That "cheap" $200/month plan? It nearly bankrupted my friend Tom when they rejected his cancer treatment as "pre-existing." Read every exclusion.

Tax Secrets Your Accountant Might Not Mention

Here's golden info most freelancers miss: Your self employed health insurance premiums are deductible above the line. Translation? They reduce your taxable income even if you don't itemize. For 2023, you can deduct 100% of premiums paid for medical, dental, and qualified long-term care insurance.

But wait – there's a catch (of course). You must:

  • Have net profit reported on Schedule C
  • Not be eligible for employer-sponsored coverage (through a spouse's job, for example)
  • Actually pay the premiums yourself (not through a business account if you're incorporated)

I screwed this up my first year. Paid premiums from my LLC account instead of personally. Lost a $7,200 deduction. Don't be me.

Liability Insurance: Your Business Parachute

Slip-and-fall accidents. Copyright infringement claims. Data breaches. These policies seem abstract until you need them. Let's get brutally practical.

Professional Liability (E&O) Wins

  • Covers negligence claims: "Your bad advice cost me money!"
  • Handles copyright/trademark disputes (vital for designers, writers)
  • Pays legal defense costs – average $50k even if you win

General Liability Must-Haves

  • Physical injury coverage (client slips in your office)
  • Property damage (you spill coffee on $10k prototype)
  • Advertising injury (libel/slander in your marketing)

Real talk: Bundling these as a Business Owner's Policy (BOP) typically saves 15-20%. My current BOP through Hiscox runs $78/month for $1M coverage. Worth every penny when a client threatened to sue over missed deadlines last year (they settled for $8k – covered).

How Much Coverage is Enough?

Blanket recommendations are useless. Base limits on:

Industry Standard:Ask peers what they carry (construction vs consulting differ wildly)
Client Requirements:Many corporate contracts mandate $1M+ liability
Worst-Case Costs:What would bankruptcy-level disaster cost? Insure that
Asset Protection:Enough to shield personal assets if sued

For most solopreneurs, $1M per occurrence/$2M aggregate is solid. Graphic designers might skate with $500k. Contractors? $2M minimum.

Disability Insurance: The Silent Killer of Savings

Stats don't lie: 25% of workers will become disabled for 3+ months before retirement. Yet 65% of freelancers have no coverage. Why? It feels abstract. Until it isn't.

Two types matter:

  • Short-Term Disability (STD): Replaces 60-70% income for 3-6 months. Premiums: $25-$50/month.
  • Long-Term Disability (LTD): Kicks in after 90-180 days; can last years. Premiums: 1-3% of income.

Critical features to demand:

  • Own-Occupation Definition: Pays if you can't do YOUR specific job (not just "any job")
  • Non-Cancelable: Insurer can't drop you if health changes
  • Residual Benefits: Partial payments if you return part-time
  • COLA Rider: Adjusts for inflation during long claims

Skip "any occupation" policies. They're cheaper but useless. If you're a surgeon and lose fine motor skills, they'll say "Go be a Walmart greeter."

Where to Actually Buy Self Employed Insurance

Marketplaces overwhelm. Agents push expensive bundles. Here's how to navigate:

Source Best For Average Cost Savings Gotchas
Healthcare.gov (ACA Marketplace) Health insurance with subsidies Up to 80% if income qualifies Limited networks; complex enrollment rules
Independent Brokers Liability/disability policies None (but access to multiple carriers) Commission bias toward certain insurers
Direct Insurers (State Farm, Allstate) Bundling home/auto with business 5-15% multi-policy discounts Often lack specialized freelance products
Freelancer-Specific Platforms (Next, Thimble) Pay-as-you-go liability 20-50% for project-based work Coverage gaps between projects

Personally? I use an independent broker for liability/disability and Healthcare.gov for health insurance. Tried those "insurtech" apps. Canceled after Thimble denied a claim for work done "outside app hours." Never again.

Timing Your Purchases Strategically

Insurance isn't just what you buy – it's WHEN. Genius moves:

  • Health Insurance: Open Enrollment = Nov 1-Jan 15. Special enrollment if life changes (marriage, move)
  • Liability Policies: Buy BEFORE signing client contracts requiring proof
  • Disability: Apply when youngest – premiums skyrocket after 45

Biggest mistake? Waiting until you're sick or sued. Underwriting gets brutal. I applied for disability coverage after turning 40. Premiums doubled versus quotes at age 35.

Self Employed Insurance FAQs (Real Questions I Get Daily)

"Can I deduct self employed insurance?"

Health insurance premiums? Absolutely – reduces taxable income. Disability premiums? Only if paid with after-tax dollars (benefits become tax-free). Liability premiums? Business expense deduction.

"How much should self employed health insurance cost?"

Expect $450-$1,200/month for decent coverage. But location matters: NYC costs 60% more than Omaha. Age kills too: 50-year-olds pay triple what 25-year-olds pay.

"Is business insurance for self employed worth it?"

Depends. Graphic designer working remotely? Maybe skip general liability. Consultant meeting clients onsite? 100% mandatory. Landscaper? Don't even think about operating without it.

"What's the cheapest self employed insurance?"

Trap question. That $29/month liability policy? Probably covers nothing useful. Real minimums: Catastrophic health plans ($230/month), pay-per-project liability ($5/hour worked). Still, you get what you pay for.

Red Flags That Should Scare You Off

Not all insurance is created equal. Run if you see:

  • "Assurant" health plans: They're just discount cards – not ACA-compliant insurance
  • Policies excluding "cyber incidents": Meaningful for any online business
  • No consent-to-rate clause: Lets insurers hike premiums without warning
  • Claims paid "at our discretion": Translation: We'll probably deny

I learned this lesson with a professional liability policy excluding "intellectual property disputes." As a writer? Worthless. Fought six months to cancel.

Audit Your Coverage Yearly

Your business evolves. Your insurance should too. Every January, I review:

Revenue ChangesHigher income = need more liability coverage
New ServicesCoaching added? Update E&O policy
Client LocationsWorking in new states? Verify coverage territory
Equipment ValueBought $5k camera? Increase property limits

Last year's discovery: My policy didn't cover virtual consultations. Added endorsement for $12/month.

Making the Final Decision

Choose insurers like you'd choose a business partner. Dig into:

  • AM Best Ratings: Never buy from companies below "A-"
  • Complaint Ratios: Check National Association of Insurance Commissioners data
  • Agent Accessibility: Can you reach a human at 3 AM during crisis?

Look, insurance sucks until you need it. That dentist bill for $1,200? Paid entirely thanks to decent health insurance. That client who sued for $25k? Liability policy covered every penny. Protecting your livelihood isn't sexy. But neither is bankruptcy.

Still debating whether self employed insurance is worth it? Ask yourself this: What's one month of income worth to you? Now imagine losing six months. Exactly.

Leave a Comments

Recommended Article