Okay, let's get real about pit bulls. You've probably heard a million opinions, but when you actually start looking into types of breeds of pit bulls, things get confusing fast. I remember when I first adopted my dog, people kept calling her a pit bull when she's actually an American Staffordshire Terrier. That confusion happens all the time.
Here's the kicker: "Pit bull" isn't a single breed. It's like saying "retriever" – there are different types beneath that umbrella. Mislabeling causes so many problems, from housing restrictions to unfair stereotypes. Let's cut through the noise.
Why These Dogs Get Mislabeled So Often
Picture this: you're at the shelter and see a muscular dog with a broad head. Staff might call it a pit bull mix, but that label gets slapped on so many dogs. Studies show animal shelter workers misidentify breeds over 75% of the time when checked against DNA tests. That's wild, right?
The term "pit bull" originally referred to dogs used in bull-baiting, but modern types of pit bull breeds couldn't be more different. What most people don't realize? Four distinct breeds make up the core pit bull category, each with unique histories and traits. Getting this wrong means you might bring home a dog totally unsuited to your lifestyle.
The Four Legitimate Pit Bull Breeds Explained
When we talk about actual recognized breeds, these are the main players in the pit bull world. I've seen too many websites lump them all together, but they've got important differences.
American Pit Bull Terrier (APBT)
This is the OG pit bull. Developed in 19th century England for blood sports (which we obviously don't do anymore), APBTs were brought to America where they became farm dogs. My neighbor has one named Tank – 55 pounds of pure muscle who thinks he's a lapdog.
| Trait | Details | Reality Check |
|---|---|---|
| Size Range | 30-65 lbs (males larger) | Don't believe "90 lb pit bull" claims – that's usually a mix |
| Temperament | High energy, athletic, people-oriented | Prone to dog aggression (genetic trait) |
| Lifespan | 12-14 years | Watch for hip dysplasia and heart issues |
| Recognition | UKC (not AKC) | Breed standards vary by registry |
What most sites won't tell you: APBTs have intense prey drive. My friend learned this the hard way when his chased squirrels through three yards. Requires serious containment.
American Staffordshire Terrier (AmStaff)
AmStaffs split from APBTs in the 1930s when breeders wanted AKC recognition. They're stockier – think bodybuilder version. I've always found them slightly more easygoing than APBTs, but that's just my experience.
| Trait | Details | Owner Consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Size Range | 40-70 lbs | Weight limits matter in apartments |
| Temperament | Confident, intelligent, loyal | Early socialization is non-negotiable |
| Health Concerns | Cerebellar ataxia (genetic test available) | Reputable breeders test for this |
| Recognition | AKC & UKC | Papers matter for breed-specific legislation |
Red flag I've noticed: Some backyard breeders market "XL AmStaffs" which are usually American Bully mixes. Real AmStaffs have strict size standards.
Staffordshire Bull Terrier (Staffy)
The compact powerhouse. Bred in England as nanny dogs (yes, really), Staffies weigh just 24-38 lbs but pack serious muscle. Their smile is unmistakable once you've seen it.
Must-know: Staffies consistently rank among the best with children in temperament studies. UK Kennel Club calls them "the children's nursemaid." But they still need supervision – no dog should be left alone with kids.
| Trait | Details | Practical Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 24-38 lbs | Easier for renters with weight restrictions |
| Energy Level | Moderate (30-45 min exercise/day) | Better for apartments than APBTs |
| Health Risks | L-2-HGA & HC (genetic tests available) | Reputable breeders test parents |
| Unique Feature | "Staffy smile" (submissive grin) | Often mistaken for aggression by strangers |
Downside nobody mentions: Staffies snore like freight trains. My cousin's sounds like a chainsaw.
American Bully
The newcomer (developed 1990s). Bred from APBTs and AmStaffs with other bulldog types. Controversial among purists, but growing fast. You've seen those Instagram dogs with huge heads – that's usually an XL Bully.
| Category | Height | Weight | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 17" (front leg to shoulder) | Under 50 lbs | Not actually pocket-sized! | |
| Standard | 17-20" | 50-70 lbs | Most common type |
| Classic | 17-20" | Lighter frame | Less bulky than standard |
| XL | Over 20" | 80-150+ lbs | Controversial due to extreme breeding |
Straight talk: Many XL Bullies have joint issues from rapid growth. If buying, demand OFA hip certifications. Better yet – adopt an adult so you know what you're getting.
Fake Pit Bulls: Breeds Often Mistaken for Pit Bull Types
Walk through any shelter and you'll see "pit bull mixes" that are clearly something else. DNA studies reveal most are total mutts. Here's why mislabeling happens:
Common Imposters
American Bulldogs: Those jowly 100+ lb giants? Not pit bulls. Used on farms for centuries. Need tons of space.
Bull Terriers (the Target dog): Egg-shaped head gives them away. Prone to obsessive behaviors.
Cane Corsos: Mastiff relatives with guarding instincts. Not beginner dogs.
Dogo Argentinos: Bred for big game hunting. Illegal in some countries.
Boxers: People confuse the underbite. Much more energetic than Staffies.
DNA tests reveal the truth. One study showed only 15% of shelter "pit bulls" had significant APBT DNA. The rest were mixes of labs, boxers, even dachshunds!
Choosing Your Type of Pit Bull Breed
This decision matters more than most realize. I've seen people get APBTs for apartment life – disaster waiting to happen. Let's match breeds to lifestyles:
| Lifestyle Factor | Best Match | Think Twice About |
|---|---|---|
| Apartment Living | Staffordshire Bull Terrier | American Bully XL (space needs) |
| First-Time Owners | Staffordshire Bull Terrier | American Pit Bull Terrier (training demands) |
| Active Outdoorsy | APBT or AmStaff | Pocket Bully (stamina limitations) |
| Families w/Kids | Staffordshire Bull Terrier | XL Bullies (size mismatch) |
| Limited Budget | Rescue Staffy or AmStaff | XL Bully (massive food/vet costs) |
Cost Breakdown Most Sites Hide
Thinking of buying a "rare blue nose pit bull"? Let's talk numbers:
Upfront Costs
- Reputable breeder: $1,500-$3,000 (with health testing)
- Backyard breeder: $500-$800 (likely health/behavior issues)
- Adoption: $50-$300 (includes shots/spay)
Monthly Expenses
- Food (quality): $60-$150/month
- Insurance: $40-$100/month
- Preventatives: $20-$40/month
Surgery example: TPLO for torn ACL? $4,000-$7,000. Insurance matters.
Legal Landmines: Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL)
This is critical. Over 700 U.S. cities restrict types of breeds of pit bulls. Some ban them outright. I helped a client fight an eviction notice last year – took 8 months to prove his AmStaff wasn't a "banned breed."
Hotspot Areas:
- Entire states: Colorado, Missouri
- Major cities: Miami, Denver, Sioux City
- Often banned: APBTs, AmStaffs, Bullies
- Usually exempt: Staffordshire Bull Terriers (separate classification)
Red alert: Homeowner's insurance? Many companies refuse pit bull types. State Farm is most breed-neutral. Always disclose – policy cancellation is brutal.
Training Pitfalls Specific to Pit Bull Types
Trainers won't always tell you this: Positive reinforcement works, but pit bulls need unique approaches. Forget shock collars – they backfire spectacularly.
Critical Training Focus Areas:
1. Leash reactivity: Genetics make them pull toward dogs/squirrels
2. Impulse control: "Leave it" saves lives
3. Socialization windows: Miss before 16 weeks? Much harder later
4. Resource guarding: Common in rescues
5. Bite inhibition: Non-negotiable for powerful jaws
Best $300 I ever spent? Professional trainer specializing in terriers. Fixed my rescue's lunging in 3 sessions.
Health Issues Across Types of Pit Bull Breeds
Let's be blunt: Bad breeding causes most problems. Reputable breeders test for:
| Condition | Common In | Prevention |
|---|---|---|
| Hip Dysplasia | Bullies & AmStaffs | OFA/PennHIP screening |
| Demodectic Mange | APBTs especially | Don't breed carriers |
| Heart Disease | All types | Annual vet checks |
| Skin Allergies | White-coated dogs | Limited ingredient diets |
| L-2-HGA/HC | Staffordshire Bull Terriers | Genetic testing parents |
Vet secret: Pit bulls metabolize anesthesia differently. Always remind your vet – it affects dosing.
Rescue vs. Breeder: The Unvarnished Truth
Adoption appeals to many, but it's risky with pit bulls. My first rescue had undisclosed bite history. Scary situation.
Rescue Pros:
- Cost effective ($300 vs $3000)
- Often already spayed/vaccinated
- Saving a life
Rescue Cons:
- Unknown genetics/temperament
- Common behavior issues (fear, resource guarding)
- May have been abused
Breeder Pros:
- Health-tested parents
- Predictable temperament
- Early socialization
Breeder Cons:
- Cost ($1500-$5000)
- Waitlists (up to 2 years)
- Scams abound ("teacup pit bulls" don't exist)
My take? For first-timers, go with a reputable breeder. Experienced owners? Rescue saves lives. Either way, meet the parents whenever possible.
Equipment That Actually Works for Pit Bull Types
Standard gear fails with these powerful dogs. After testing dozens of products:
Must-Haves:
- Harness: Ruffwear Front Range ($60) – stops pulling
- Leash: 6ft biothane ($25) – won't rip if they lunge
- Chew toys: Goughnuts indestructible ($40) – lasts months
- Crates: Impact Collapsible ($300) – escape-proof
Skip flexi-leashes – too dangerous with high prey drive.
Your Top Questions on Types of Breeds of Pit Bulls Answered
Are pit bulls naturally aggressive?
Nope. Temperament tests by the American Temperament Test Society show APBTs pass at 86.8% – higher than beagles (80.3%) or chihuahuas (68.8%). But genetics matter: APBTs were bred for dog aggression. Never leave them unsupervised with other pets.
How long do pit bulls live?
It varies wildly by breed. Staffies live 12-14 years. XL Bullies? Sadly, often just 5-8 years due to size-related issues. Keep them lean – obesity cuts lifespan by 2+ years.
Do pit bulls have locking jaws?
Total myth. University of Florida studies found their jaw structure is identical to other dogs. But they are determined – once they grab something, they don't quit easily.
Can I rent with a pit bull type?
Tough but possible. Offer pet resumes with training certificates. Get Canine Good Citizen certified. Offer additional deposit. Avoid corporate landlords – seek private owners.
Why do some pit bulls have cropped ears?
Historically for protection in fights (less to grab). Now mostly cosmetic and controversial. Illegal in many countries. Natural ears are healthier and express emotion better.
Are male or female pit bulls better?
Males are typically more affectionate but prone to same-sex aggression. Females are often more independent. Spay/neuter is mandatory either way – intact pit bulls are more unpredictable.
Final Reality Check Before You Commit
Look, I love these dogs. But I've also seen too many surrendered when reality hits. Before choosing types of pit bull breeds:
1. Check local laws
2. Call your insurance provider
3. Interview trainers in advance
4. Calculate real costs (double your estimate)
5. Test breed restrictions at rentals
6. Be brutally honest about your time/energy
The hardest truth? These dogs read emotions like therapists. If you're stressed, they'll be stressed. Their worst behaviors come from unstable owners.
But get it right? You'll have the most loyal companion imaginable. My AmStaff waits by the door like a furry stopwatch. Wouldn't trade him for anything – despite the snoring.
Leave a Comments