Okay, let's talk about finding amazing places to stay in St Augustine FL. Honestly? It's overwhelming when you start looking. Historic inns, beach resorts, vacation rentals – how do you even choose? I learned this the hard way when my family visited last spring and we booked a place that looked gorgeous online but turned out to be next to a noisy parking lot. The lesson? Knowing exactly what you're getting matters.
This guide covers everything I wish I knew before booking our trip. We'll dive into historic district gems, beachfront properties, budget spots, and even pet-friendly options. I'll give you real pricing, specific locations, and honest pros and cons. Forget generic lists – you'll get the actual details that make or break a St Augustine stay.
Why Your Accommodation Choice Matters in St Augustine
St Augustine isn't like other Florida destinations. It's America's oldest city, so where you stay impacts your experience. Stay downtown? You're steps from the Castillo de San Marcos and St George Street's energy. Beachfront? You trade history for ocean views. Vacation rental? Perfect for groups but might mean driving everywhere.
When I first searched for places to stay in St Augustine FL, nobody mentioned how parking works. Big mistake. Historic district hotels often charge $15-$25 nightly for parking, while beach resorts usually include it. Small details like this matter.
Key Factors to Consider
- Location: Walking distance to attractions? Or need a car?
- Parking: Added costs? Availability?
- Seasonal Rates: Winter rates can double summer prices
- Walkability: Cobblestone streets aren't suitcase-friendly
Last March, we stayed at a B&B just off Aviles Street. Waking up to church bells and walking to coffee shops was magical. But dragging our bags over those uneven sidewalks? Not so much. Pack light if you're staying downtown.
Historic District Hotels and Inns (The Heart of the Action)
If you want to immerse yourself in history, this is where to stay. We're talking converted 18th-century homes, courtyards with fountains, and gas lanterns. But be ready for smaller rooms and occasional noise.
| Property | Address | Price Range/Night | Unique Perks | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Casa Monica Resort & Spa | 95 Cordova St | $280-$450 | Rooftop pool, walk to Flagler College | Valet parking only ($32/night) |
| St. George Inn | 4 St George St #101 | $220-$350 | Balconies overlooking City Gate | No elevator (historic building) |
| Bayfront Westcott House | 146 Avenida Menendez | $190-$300 | Waterfront views, homemade breakfast included | Small bathrooms in some rooms |
What most blogs won't tell you? Rooms facing streets like Cordova or King get trolley noise starting at 8:30 AM. Ask for courtyard-facing rooms. My sister stayed at St. George Inn last fall – her balcony view of the Bridge of Lions was spectacular, but she wishes she'd packed earplugs for weekend nights.
Historic District Budget Options
Yes, affordable places exist downtown:
- Victorian House B&B: $150-$220/night. 11 Cadiz St. Quirky Victorian charm but shared bathrooms in some rooms
- Carriage Way Inn: $135-$200/night. 70 Cuna St. Includes breakfast, but rooms are tiny
Beachfront St Augustine FL Accommodations
Prefer salt air over historic charm? The beaches stretch along Anastasia Island. Vilano Beach feels secluded while St. Augustine Beach has more dining options.
| Property | Beach Area | Price Range/Night | Best For | Distance to Downtown |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Guy Harvey Resort | St. Augustine Beach | $240-$400 | Families (lazy river pool!) | 15 min drive |
| Vilano Beach Resort | Vilano Beach | $260-$500 | Romantic getaways | 10 min drive |
| Hilton St. Augustine | Historic Bayfront | $220-$380 | Business travelers | Walkable |
Important note about beach properties: Not all have swimmable beaches year-round. Erosion can be brutal. Call ahead and ask about beach conditions – we learned this after arriving at a "beachfront" spot where the water was 100 yards away during low tide. Major bummer.
Beach Stay Advantages
- Free parking usually included
- Larger rooms than downtown
- Resort amenities (pools, tiki bars)
Beach Stay Disadvantages
- Driving required for historic sites
- Limited dining walkability
- Beach access fees at some condos
Vacation Rentals: When They Make Sense
Booking a condo or house? Fantastic for groups of 4+. But location is everything. I'd skip generic VRBO listings without specifics.
Top Rental Zones in St Augustine:
- Davis Shores: Residential area near downtown. Quiet streets, 15-min walk to Old City. (Average: $220/night)
- Anastasia Island: Between beach and downtown. Best for families needing space. (Average: $250/night)
- Crescent Beach: Further south. Peaceful but 25-min drive to attractions. (Average: $200/night)
Rental Red Flag: If a listing says "10 minutes to downtown" without specifying driving or walking? It's driving. Actual walkable rentals are rare and book fast.
Budget-Friendly Places to Stay in St Augustine FL
Good news: You don't need to splurge. Here's where to save:
- Sixties Motel: 110 San Marco Ave. Retro vibe, pool, $89-$129/night. 5-min drive to downtown. Surprisingly clean!
- Super 8 by Wyndham: 2675 N Ponce de Leon Blvd. Basic but functional at $75-$110. Includes breakfast.
- St. Augustine Hostel: 32 Treasury St. Shared dorms $35/bed. Right downtown! But... shared bathrooms aren't for everyone.
These places to stay in St Augustine FL sacrifice charm for savings. The hostel is legitimately downtown though – you can't beat that location on a budget.
Pet-Friendly Stays (Because Fido Vacations Too)
Traveling with dogs? Some spots roll out the red carpet:
- La Fiesta Ocean Inn: St. Augustine Beach. $10/night pet fee. Beach access path onsite!
- Casa de Solana B&B: Historic District. Allows dogs under 25 lbs. Rare for downtown.
- Westcott House: Mentioned earlier. Allows pets in ground-floor rooms.
Word of caution: Many historic inns have steep stairs unsuitable for older dogs. Always call about pet policies – "pet-friendly" can mean anything from "dogs under 20 lbs only" to "all pets welcome".
When to Book for the Best Deals
Timing makes a huge difference in price:
| Season | Dates | Price Impact | Booking Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peak Season | Dec-Apr, July | +40-60% higher rates | Book 6 months early |
| Shoulder Season | May, Sept-Nov | Moderate pricing | Look for last-minute cancellations |
| Low Season | Aug, early Dec | Discounted rates | Check for flash sales |
Local insight: Avoid booking during "Nights of Lights" (mid-Nov to Jan 31) unless you love crowds. Hotels triple rates.
What Nobody Tells You About St Augustine Stays
After multiple visits, here's my unfiltered advice:
1. Trolley Noise is Real
Historic district rooms facing streets hear trolleys narrating history starting at 8:30 AM. Bring white noise machines.
2. "Beach View" ≠ Beach Access
Some condo rentals require crossing A1A highway to reach sand. Verify actual beach access routes.
3. Resort Fees Slip In
Beach resorts often add $25-$35/night "amenity fees". Always ask about extra charges.
St Augustine Accommodation FAQs
What's the most walkable area for first-time visitors?
Hands down: Historic District between King Street and the bayfront. You'll pay more but save on parking and time.
Are vacation rentals cheaper than hotels?
Only for groups of 4+. For couples, hotels often offer better value with included amenities. Cleaning fees kill rental deals for small groups.
Should I stay on Anastasia Island?
Great if you prioritize beach time and have a car. Not ideal if you plan multiple historic site visits – the bridge traffic gets old.
What's the parking situation really like?
Historic district parking is tough. Hotels charge $18-$35/night for limited spaces. Beach hotels usually include free parking. Factor this into your budget.
Are there adults-only places to stay in St Augustine FL?
Few options exist. Casa de Solana (B&B) and The Collector (luxury inn) maintain quieter atmospheres by limiting children.
Making Your Final Decision
After exploring all these places to stay in St Augustine FL, how to choose? Match your travel style:
- History Buffs: Downtown inns like Bayfront Westcott
- Beach Lovers: Vilano Beach Resort or Guy Harvey
- Budget Travelers: Sixties Motel or hostel
- Family Groups: Anastasia Island vacation rental
Final piece of advice? Call the property directly after booking online. Confirm your room location and any restrictions. Our last-minute request for a quiet room at St. George Inn made all the difference.
Truth is, there's no single "best" place to stay in St Augustine FL. It depends entirely on what experience you're after. But armed with these specifics – real prices, locations, and insider drawbacks – you'll dodge the tourist traps and find your perfect match. Happy planning!
Leave a Comments