You know, I get this question a lot when chatting with folks about politics: "Is Montana a blue or red state?" My neighbor asked me this just last week while we were shoveling snow. Honestly, it's not as simple as slapping a red or blue label on it. Let me walk you through what I've learned living here and crunching the numbers.
Montana's Political Identity: Red Dominance with Blue Exceptions
Most national pundits call Montana solidly red these days. They're not entirely wrong – Republicans dominate statewide offices. But anyone who actually lives here knows there's more nuance. We've elected Democratic governors and senators even while voting Republican in presidential races. It's like we enjoy keeping everyone guessing.
I remember the 2020 election night clearly. My entire feed was split between Tester supporters and Daines fans. That race showed how Montana isn't some monolith. Urban Missoula feels like a different planet compared to ranch country near Billings.
The Presidential Lens: How Montana Votes Nationally
Look, if we're talking presidential elections, Montana has been red for decades. But the margins tell an interesting story:
| Year | Republican Candidate | Democrat Candidate | Margin of Victory |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Trump (56.9%) | Biden (40.5%) | R +16.4% |
| 2016 | Trump (56.2%) | Clinton (35.4%) | R +20.8% |
| 2012 | Romney (55.3%) | Obama (41.7%) | R +13.6% |
See that tightening margin in 2020? Makes me wonder if we're seeing subtle shifts. But still, asking "is Montana a blue or red state" in presidential terms gets you a clear answer: deep red.
State-Level Surprises: Where Blue Persists
Here's where it gets messy. While we reliably send Republicans to the White House, we've split tickets like crazy:
Governor Elections
- 2020: Greg Gianforte (R) wins after 16 years of Democratic governors
- 2016: Steve Bullock (D) re-elected by 4 points while Trump carried state by 20
- 2008: Brian Schweitzer (D) wins re-election in landslide (65%!) during Obama loss
Schweitzer was fascinating to watch. That guy could wear a bolo tie and talk about cattle ranching while vetoing Republican bills. Made conservatives grit their teeth but he understood rural appeal.
Senate Representation
| Senator | Party | First Elected | Key Issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jon Tester (D) | Democrat | 2006 | Veterans' affairs, agriculture, public lands |
| Steve Daines (R) | Republican | 2014 | Energy development, tax cuts, gun rights |
Having one senator from each party? That's so Montana. Whenever someone asks "is Montana a blue or red state?" I point to our split Senate delegation. We're literally divided.
Why This Split Personality? Key Factors Driving Montana Politics
From my perspective after 15 years in Billings, these forces shape our elections:
The Urban-Rural Tug of War
Our seven small cities are becoming more liberal while the vast rural areas grow more conservative. Missoula (where my cousin teaches) might as well be Portland with its environmental activism and Bernie stickers. Meanwhile, oil towns like Sidney feel like Texas outposts.
- Blue Counties: Missoula, Gallatin, Lewis & Clark (state government workers!), Silver Bow
- Deep Red Counties: Richland, Liberty, Sanders, Prairie
- Swing Counties: Yellowstone (Billings), Cascade (Great Falls)
Top Election Issues for Montanans
Knocking doors during the 2018 Senate race taught me what actually moves voters:
- Public land access: Try proposing restrictions and see what happens. Even Republicans get nervous here.
- Resource industries: Mining, logging, drilling jobs sway whole communities
- Cost of living: Housing prices in Bozeman are insane now – locals are furious
- Healthcare access: Rural hospitals closing hits hard
Notice what's missing? National culture war stuff rarely dominates here like it does on cable news. Except maybe gun rights – that one cuts deep.
Recent Power Shifts: The GOP Takeover
2020 changed everything. Republicans finally flipped the governor's mansion and now control:
Montana Government Control (2024)
• Governor: Republican
• State Senate: 34R - 16D
• State House: 68R - 32D
• Both U.S. House seats: Republican
This unified control let them pass conservative wish-list items. Some worked fine but others... remember that voting restriction bill that caused chaos in tribal communities? Yeah, that backfired badly in some counties.
Could Montana Ever Turn Blue Again?
Possible? Maybe. Likely soon? Doubt it. Here's why:
| Factor | Helps Democrats | Helps Republicans |
|---|---|---|
| Population Growth | New arrivals from blue states | Growth concentrated in already red areas |
| Native Vote | Increasing turnout on reservations | Voter ID laws creating barriers |
| Economic Shifts | Tech jobs in Missoula/Bozeman | Resource industry still dominates |
But honestly? Most folks I talk to are getting more polarized. My bowling league friend switched parties over COVID mandates. Said he'd "never vote for a Democrat again." That intensity worries me.
Still, writing off Democrats is naive. Tester keeps winning by campaigning differently than national Dems. He shows up at county fairs wearing flannel shirts and actually listens. Novel concept, right?
Straight Answers: Your Montana Politics FAQs
Has Montana always been a red state?
Not even close. We had Democratic governors for 16 straight years before 2020. Historically we're more purple than deep red.
Why does Montana elect Democrats statewide but vote Republican for president?
Montanans hate being told what to do – including by national parties. Local Dems run as moderates focused on Montana-specific issues, not coastal progressives.
Do Native American voters impact elections?
Big time. Tribes delivered Tester's margin in 2018. But recent voting law changes made some rez voting harder, which is just wrong if you ask me.
Is Montana becoming more Republican?
On balance yes, especially since 2016. Rural areas shifted hard right while cities grow bluer but more slowly. Overall math favors Republicans now.
Could population growth turn Montana blue?
The California/Oregon transplants do lean liberal. But they're settling in already blue counties. To flip the state, Dems need to stop losing rural areas by 40-point margins.
The Verdict: What Color Is Montana Really?
So after all this, is Montana a blue or red state? Currently, it's functionally red at the federal level and increasingly red statewide. But calling it a deep red state ignores our history of ticket-splitting and that stubborn Democratic senator.
If you forced me to pick a color? I'd say Montana is crimson – red with lingering traces of blue. Not quite purple anymore, but not Wyoming-red either. That blend makes our politics unexpectedly fascinating, even if it drives strategists crazy.
What really settles the "is Montana a blue or red state" debate? Watch how we vote when Tester retires. If Republicans finally take that seat, then yeah – we're officially red country.
Leave a Comments