You know that feeling when you finish some popular bestseller and something just feels... off? That nagging sense that the arguments don't quite hold up? Yeah, me too. That's exactly why I nearly spilled my coffee when I discovered the If Books Could Kill podcast last year. It felt like finding my people.
Hosted by Michael Hobbes (you might know him from Maintenance Phase) and Peter Shamshiri (of 5-4 podcast fame), If Books Could Kill digs into those airport bestsellers that shaped public opinion but maybe shouldn't have. You know the type - the Malcolm Gladwells, the Freakonomics guys, those books everyone discussed at dinner parties but few actually fact-checked.
The Hosts Behind the Microphone
Michael brings his research chops from years as an investigative journalist, while Peter's legal training helps dissect arguments like a surgeon. Their chemistry is hilarious - imagine your two smartest friends roasting bad takes over beers. What makes If Books Could Kill podcast work so well is how they balance deep analysis with genuine laughs.
Why This Podcast Feels Like Required Reading
Remember when everyone was obsessed with "The Secret"? Or when corporate types wouldn't shut up about "Good to Great"? This show goes beyond simple criticism. They reconstruct the cultural moment when each book landed, which explains so much about why we fell for them. For instance, their episode on "The Game" made me realize how that creepy pickup artist manual actually predicted modern influencer culture.
Where else can you hear a thorough takedown of Thomas Friedman's terrible metaphors that actually makes you laugh out loud? Their "Freakonomics" episode completely changed how I view economics journalism now. I keep recommending If Books Could Kill to friends because it teaches critical thinking without feeling like homework.
What Makes If Books Could Kill Stand Out:
- They read the books so you don't have to (seriously, who has time?)
- Context matters just as much as content - they explain why certain ideas caught fire
- No sacred cows - they'll critique progressive darlings too
- Actual research with cited sources (unlike many books they cover)
- Laughter as learning tool - it's education disguised as entertainment
Must-Listen Episodes to Start With
New to If Books Could Kill podcast? Don't just dive in randomly. Their back catalog is deep, but some episodes truly stand out. I made the mistake of sampling their "Blink" episode first and got hooked - now I save new releases for my Thursday walks.
| Book Title | Original Publish Year | Why This Episode Kills | Listen Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freakonomics (Steven Levitt & Stephen Dubner) | 2005 | Exposes how cherry-picked data created misleading narratives | 98 minutes |
| The Game (Neil Strauss) | 2005 | Traces how toxic masculinity manuals evolved into modern influencer culture | 84 minutes |
| Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus (John Gray) | 1992 | Brutal takedown of pop psychology that damaged generations | 76 minutes |
| The 4-Hour Workweek (Tim Ferriss) | 2007 | Reveals why productivity porn keeps selling false dreams | 102 minutes |
| Outliers (Malcolm Gladwell) | 2008 | Shows how oversimplified success stories distort reality | 89 minutes |
Their episode on "The Bell Curve" should be required listening for anyone discussing race and IQ. Chilling how that flawed book still echoes in policy discussions. Not every If Books Could Kill episode hits equally hard though - I thought their "Atomic Habits" critique spent too much time on minor points and missed bigger issues.
Where and How to Listen
Finding If Books Could Kill podcast episodes is straightforward. They release new ones every other Thursday - usually around 60-100 minutes long. Perfect for your commute or doing dishes. Here's where I listen:
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Google Podcasts
Pocket Casts
Direct RSS Feed
The show doesn't have ads mid-episode (hallelujah!), though they do brief promos for other shows at start/end. You can support them via Patreon for bonus episodes - their donor-only takedown of "Rich Dad Poor Dad" was painfully accurate about financial grifters.
Typical Episode Structure
- Intro banter (5-10 mins): Hosts catch up, recent drama related to book topics
- Author background (10-15 mins): Where did this writer come from? What's their deal?
- Book breakdown (40-60 mins): Chapter-by-chapter analysis with research interjections
- Cultural impact (15-20 mins): How this book broke brains and shaped discussions
- Listener questions (occasional): Clever mailbag segments
Frequently Asked Questions About the Podcast
How often do new If Books Could Kill podcast episodes come out?
Roughly every two weeks, though sometimes they take breaks between seasons. No set schedule like clockwork - they drop when ready.
Do I need to read the books before listening?
God no! Half the point is they suffer through them for you. I tried reading "The Secret" after their episode and couldn't finish - their summary was painfully sufficient.
Why aren't they covering [my most hated bestseller]?
They take suggestions! Email them or tweet @bookkillpod. Their backlog grows based on listener rage requests. Still waiting on "Who Moved My Cheese?" myself.
Is If Books Could Kill only about non-fiction?
So far yes - they focus on books claiming to be factual. Fiction gets different criticism rules. Though I'd kill for their take on "Atlas Shrugged".
Can I use this for my book club?
Absolutely. My group did this with "Guns, Germs and Steel" - listened to the episode then discussed. Sparked better arguments than the book itself.
The Cultural Impact - Why It Matters
What If Books Could Kill podcast does brilliantly is connect intellectual history to present-day nonsense. Their episode on "The End of History" felt spookily relevant during recent global conflicts. By showing how ideas travel from page to policy, they reveal why bad books cause real harm.
I've noticed their critiques extend beyond books too. After listening to several episodes, you start spotting the same logical fallacies in TED Talks, op-eds, even boardroom presentations. It's like gaining x-ray vision for BS.
Not every episode lands perfectly. Sometimes they dunk too hard on easy targets. I wish they'd tackle more recent bestsellers instead of 90s relics. And Peter's lawyerly tangents occasionally derail Michael's stronger research points. Still, these are minor quibbles in an otherwise brilliant show.
Beyond the Podcast - Critical Reading Resources
Inspired by If Books Could Kill? Here's how to sharpen your own BS detector:
- Follow the hosts: Michael Hobbes (@rottenindenmark) and Peter Shamshiri (@petershamshiri) drop great reading suggestions on Twitter
- Fact-checking sites: Media Bias/Fact Check, SciCheck, Retraction Watch
- Logical fallacy guides: Your Logical Fallacy Is (website), Critical Thinking (book by Tom Chatfield)
- Related podcasts: Maintenance Phase, You're Wrong About, Behind the Bastards
What Listeners Gain Long-Term
- Recognizing cherry-picked data in news reports
- Spotting correlation/causation errors in studies
- Understanding how narratives get constructed
- Identifying oversimplified solutions to complex problems
- Developing healthier skepticism towards gurus
The Verdict - Why You Should Hit Play
Look, in a world drowning in misinformation, If Books Could Kill podcast feels like an intellectual life raft. It's not dry academia - the hosts swear, laugh, and get properly outraged. After bingeing their back catalog, I find myself automatically dissecting arguments at work meetings. My partner says I've become insufferable at spotting logical fallacies in commercials.
Is it perfect? No podcast is. Some episodes run long, their inside jokes can exclude new listeners, and they haven't covered any of my personal book nemeses yet. But when they nail an episode - like their devastating take on "The Rules" dating manual - it's some of the smartest entertainment around.
Give If Books Could Kill a shot during your next commute. Start with a book you've actually read or heard about. By minute twenty, you'll either be nodding along or texting friends "you gotta hear this takedown." Just don't blame me when you start side-eyeing your boss's favorite business bestseller.
Leave a Comments