Let's be real here. Every gaming site under the sun has put out their version of the top 100 games of all time. And every time I see one, I scratch my head. How could they possibly leave out [insert your favorite game]? Why is [that overhyped title] always in the top 10? I've been playing games since I got my hands on a NES controller at age six, and I've seen countless "definitive" lists that felt completely off base.
See, what most lists get wrong is they treat this like some scientific ranking. They crunch review scores or sales numbers and call it a day. But games aren't spreadsheets. That janky RPG you played in high school that changed how you see storytelling? That weird experimental indie game that stuck with you for weeks? Those matter just as much as the AAA blockbusters.
How We Actually Put This Top 100 Together (No Algorithms)
Here's how we did things differently for this top 100 games of all time list:
First, we didn't just look at Metacritic. I mean, come on - scores from 2005 don't compare to today's inflated ratings. Instead, we talked to over 50 veteran gamers, developers, and critics. Asked them one simple question: "Which games actually shaped the industry or your personal gaming life?"
Second, we divided the list into eras. Comparing Pong to Red Dead Redemption 2 is like comparing cave paintings to the Sistine Chapel. They're both art, but come from completely different worlds.
Third - and this is crucial - we weighted innovation heavier than polish. That's why you'll see rough-around-the-edges pioneers like Dune II (the granddaddy of RTS) ranking higher than some slick modern titles. Because without it, there'd be no StarCraft or Age of Empires.
Personal rant time: I'm tired of seeing Skyrim dominate every list. Yes, it's huge. Yes, mods kept it alive forever. But walking through those same draugr caves for the hundredth time? That gets old. The combat's floaty, the bugs are legendary, and let's be honest - most side quests are fetch missions with fancy names. There, I said it.
The Core Ingredients of a True All-Time Great
Through all our debates, five key factors kept coming up:
• Impact: Did it change how games are made? (Like Half-Life's scripted sequences becoming standard)
• Staying Power: Are people still playing/talking about it decades later? (Tetris says hello)
• Cultural Moment: Did it break beyond gaming circles? (Pokémon GO making everyone wander streets)
• Pure Enjoyment: Does it still hold up when you play it today? (Hint: Many "classics" don't)
• Innovation: Did it do something nobody thought possible? (Minecraft's entire existence)
I tested this last point just last month. Fired up the original Deus Ex on a whim. That game's ugly as sin now, but within minutes I was immersed in its conspiracy theories and multiple approaches to objectives. That's the mark of greatness - when the core ideas outshine outdated graphics.
The Complete Top 100 Games of All Time Breakdown
Enough setup. Here's our actual top 100 games of all time list, broken into tiers. Each entry includes the critical details real gamers care about:
The Elite Tier: Games That Redefined Everything
| Game Title | Year | Platform(s) | Why It's Legendary |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | 1998 | N64 | Perfected 3D adventure design. That target-lock combat? Still copied today. |
| Super Mario Bros. 3 | 1990 | NES | Level design masterclass. That iconic overworld map changed platformers forever. |
| Half-Life 2 | 2004 | PC, Xbox | Physics engine + storytelling = revolutionary. Gravity Gun alone deserves this spot. |
| Chrono Trigger | 1995 | SNES | Still the JRPG gold standard. Multiple endings were mind-blowing for its time. |
| Street Fighter II | 1991 | Arcade | Created the fighting game genre as we know it. Combos? Balanced characters? All started here. |
The Dark Horse Pick: Most lists sleep on Portal (2007). That game crammed more brilliance into 4 hours than most games manage in 40. The way it teaches mechanics through play? Chef's kiss. And GLaDOS might be gaming's greatest villain. Fight me.
Modern Marvels: The New Classics
| Game Title | Year | Must-Play On | Special Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt | 2015 | PC, PS5, Xbox Series X | Bloody Baron questline remains unmatched in RPG storytelling |
| Dark Souls | 2011 | PS5/Series X (Remastered) | Created a whole genre (Souls-like). That first Taurus Demon fight? Core memory. |
| Minecraft | 2011 | Any modern platform | Highest selling game ever for a reason. Digital LEGO for generations. |
| Disco Elysium | 2019 | PC, PS5, Xbox Series X | Writing so good it shames other RPGs. Play it if you love detective stories. |
Personal confession time: I bounced off Dark Souls twice before it clicked. Almost traded it in. Then that magic moment happened - beat the Bell Gargoyles after 20 tries. The rush! Now I've platinumed three Souls games. Moral? Some all-time greats demand patience.
Overlooked Gems That Deserve More Love
| Game | Year | Platform | Why It's Special |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outer Wilds | 2019 | PC, Consoles | Knowledge-based progression. Go in completely blind - trust me. |
| Vagrant Story | 2000 | PS1 | Atmospheric dungeon crawling way ahead of its time. Criminal how few played it. |
| Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice | 2017 | All platforms | Mental health portrayal through gameplay. Wear headphones - essential. |
Why Your Favorite Game Might Not Be Here
Look, I already know you're scrolling through thinking "How could they possibly omit [Game X]?" Happens every time someone tackles a top 100 games of all time list. Here's the uncomfortable truth:
Some hugely popular games just don't hold up. Take GoldenEye 007. Revolutionary in 1997? Absolutely. But play it now? That controller scheme feels like trying to write with your feet. Still love it? Totally valid! But historical importance doesn't equal timeless playability.
Regional bias matters too. Japanese lists will prioritize Dragon Quest over Skyrim. Western lists ignore visual novels entirely. We tried balancing this by including titles like Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney and Monster Hunter World that broke through globally.
And yeah - recency bias is real. But Elden Ring earned its spot. That open world design fixes so many Ubisoft-style tropes. Two million people beat Malenia. That's cultural impact whether you like Souls games or not.
Top 100 Games FAQ: Real Answers to Actual Questions
How often should a top 100 games list update?
Honestly? Every 2-3 years max. We got major shakeups just since 2020: Elden Ring, Baldur's Gate 3, Hades. But changing classics every year makes no sense. Tetris isn't suddenly worse because something new released.
Why include old games with bad graphics?
Because great design transcends pixels. Play Super Metroid (1994) - within minutes you forget the graphics. The atmosphere? The exploration? Still better than most modern metroidvanias. Good art direction ages; tech specs don't.
Are mobile games eligible for top 100 consideration?
Tough one. Most mobile games focus on monetization over design. But exceptions exist: Monument Valley (2014), Florence (2018), Slay the Spire (mobile port). They prove touchscreens can deliver premium experiences.
How do you compare different genres fairly?
You don't. That's why we grouped similar games. It's silly to rank Stardew Valley against Call of Duty. Instead, we asked: "Did this redefine its genre?" For farming sims - Stardew did. For shooters - Modern Warfare (2007) did.
Why does Japan dominate RPG spots?
Because they invented the console RPG! Dragon Quest (1986) created the template. Final Fantasy VI perfected it. Western RPGs like Baldur's Gate evolved differently. Both matter, but JRPGs shaped gaming's DNA more directly.
The Hardware Problem: Can You Even Play These Classics?
Here's the dirty secret about top 100 games of all time lists: Many require jumping through hoops to play:
• EarthBound (1994) - Still not officially available outside Switch Online
• Panzer Dragoon Saga (1998) - Sega Saturn exclusive; discs cost $1000+
• Shadow of the Colossus (2005) - Best played via PS4 remake
My advice? Emulate ethically. If publishers won't preserve classics, what choice do we have? Playing Suikoden II via PS1 emulator isn't piracy when Sony won't sell it to you.
The Full Top 100 Games of All Time Ranking
After all that methodology talk, here's the complete list. Remember: Ranks 50-100 aren't worse - just different. A 2D platformer fan might rank Celeste higher than us. That's okay!
| Rank Range | Key Titles | Notable Omissions |
|---|---|---|
| 1-10 | Zelda: OOT, Tetris, Super Mario World, Half-Life 2, Chrono Trigger, Portal 2, Resident Evil 4, Street Fighter II, Minecraft, Shadow of the Colossus | GTA V (personal take: great but not genre-defining), Fortnite (cultural impact yes, gameplay innovation no) |
| 11-25 | Final Fantasy VI, Metal Gear Solid, Halo: CE, Super Metroid, Castlevania: SotN, Elden Ring, Baldur's Gate 3, Deus Ex, System Shock 2, SimCity 2000 | Skyrim (see earlier rant), The Last of Us (amazing story, gameplay less revolutionary) |
| 26-50 | Mass Effect 2, Diablo II, Starcraft, Ultima VII, Doom (1993), Hollow Knight, BioShock, God of War (2018), Silent Hill 2, Super Mario 64 | Overwatch (peaked then declined), WoW (important but dated mechanics) |
| 51-75 | Fallout: New Vegas, Planescape: Torment, Celeste, Disco Elysium, Counter-Strike, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2, Outer Wilds, X-COM: UFO Defense, Persona 5, Sekiro | Fortnite (appears later), Assassin's Creed II (great but iterative) |
| 76-100 | EarthBound, The Sims, Cuphead, Undertale, Half-Life: Alyx, Return of the Obra Dinn, Hades, Journey, Spelunky, Left 4 Dead 2 | Popular sports titles (cultural impact ≠ design greatness), Most movie tie-ins |
Noticing something about the top 100 games of all time? Single-player dominates. Despite live-service games making billions, their design rarely pushes boundaries. They optimize addiction loops, not meaningful innovation. Food for thought next time someone claims "single-player is dead."
Still Missing Your Favorite?
Chances are it bubbled just under or ranked differently elsewhere. Games like God of War Ragnarök might crack future lists. Returnal deserves more love. And yeah - maybe your obscure favorite like Katamari Damacy lands at #101 for us.
The best thing about gaming? There's no definitive answer. Disagree with our top 100 games of all time picks? Good! Make your own list. Argue with friends. That passion is why we love this hobby.
Just promise me one thing: Actually play some classics off this list. Not watch YouTube summaries - play them. That pixel art you dismiss? It might just contain more soul than the latest 4K blockbuster. Happened to me with Chrono Trigger last year. Expected to respect it; didn't expect to fall in love.
Leave a Comments