You know what's funny? People ask "who was Thomas Jefferson's vice president" like there's just one simple answer. Truth is, Jefferson had two completely different vice presidents during his presidency, and their stories are wilder than any political drama on TV. You've got treason plots, deadly duels, and constitutional chaos - all packed into those eight years from 1801 to 1809. Let me walk you through why this matters more than you'd think.
Straight to the point: Jefferson's first Vice President was Aaron Burr (1801-1805), and his second was George Clinton (1805-1809). But if you stop there, you're missing the juicy backstories - like how Burr nearly stole Jefferson's presidency, shot Alexander Hamilton dead, then got charged with treason. Clinton's almost an afterthought compared to that circus!
The Constitutional Mess That Created Two Vice Presidents
Here's something most textbooks gloss over: Jefferson almost didn't become president at all thanks to his own running mate. Back in 1800, the rules were seriously flawed. The Constitution originally required electoral college members to cast two votes without specifying president or VP. The top vote-getter became president, runner-up became VP - even if they hated each other's guts. What could go wrong?
Everything did. Jefferson and Burr both got 73 electoral votes in 1800. Suddenly, Burr - who was supposed to be Jefferson's VP pick - started maneuvering to steal the presidency during the House runoff vote. Can you imagine? Your own teammate trying to bench you! This mess dragged on for six days and 36 ballots in Congress before Jefferson finally won. No wonder he dropped Burr faster than a hot potato later.
How the 12th Amendment Fixed Everything
That disaster led directly to the 12th Amendment in 1804. Before this, running mates were essentially competitors. Afterward? Presidents and VPs ran as actual tickets. Smart fix, but too late for Jefferson's first term. Here's how the rules changed:
| Aspect | Original System (Pre-1804) | After 12th Amendment |
|---|---|---|
| Ballot Structure | Electors cast two votes for president | Separate votes for president and VP |
| Running Mates | No formal tickets - top two became POTUS/VP | Parties nominate specific POTUS/VP tickets |
| Jefferson's Situation | Burr technically tied him in presidential votes | Clinton explicitly ran as his subordinate |
| Consequence | Created rivals in administration | Prevented future electoral crises |
The 12th Amendment ratification was cutting it close - passed in June 1804, just months before Jefferson needed to pick a new VP for his second term. Without it, we might've seen another leadership crisis.
Aaron Burr: America's Most Dangerous Vice President
Picture this: a charming New York politician who schemed his way to within one congressional vote of the presidency... only to become the nation's most infamous criminal within three years. That's Aaron Burr, Jefferson's first VP. Honestly, the guy makes modern political scandals look tame.
Burr was like a character from a thriller novel - brilliant lawyer, Revolutionary War hero, but morally flexible. John Adams called him "unprincipled both as a public and private man," and honestly? After researching him, I get it. The man had zero loyalty.
The Hamilton Duel That Ended Everything
July 11, 1804. Weehawken, New Jersey. Burr shoots Alexander Hamilton dead at dawn. This wasn't just personal - Hamilton had spent years destroying Burr's career, calling him "dangerous" and unworthy of office. The final straw? Hamilton supported Burr's political opponent in the New York governor's race.
As VP, Burr presided over the Senate impeachment trial of Supreme Court Justice Samuel Chase just months later. Imagine that scene: a man awaiting murder charges judging another official's conduct. Surreal doesn't begin to cover it.
| Date | Event | Political Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Feb 1801 | House elects Jefferson president after 36 ballots | Burr becomes VP but Jefferson never trusts him |
| 1804 | Burr runs for NY Governor, loses badly | Blames Hamilton for sabotaging campaign |
| July 11, 1804 | Burr kills Hamilton in duel | Murder charges filed in NJ and NY |
| Nov 1804 | Jefferson dumps Burr from ticket | George Clinton becomes new VP candidate |
| 1805-1807 | Burr's western conspiracy & treason trial | Jefferson personally pushes prosecution |
The duel wasn't even Burr's worst moment. After leaving office, he traveled west and allegedly plotted to create his own independent nation from Spanish territories. Jefferson ordered his arrest for treason in 1807. The trial featured testimony from none other than future president Andrew Jackson! Burr was acquitted but fled to Europe in disgrace.
George Clinton: The Forgotten Vice President
After the Burr fireworks, George Clinton must've seemed boring by comparison - and that's exactly why Jefferson wanted him. Clinton was America's first professional politician, serving as New York's governor for 21 years before becoming VP. Safe, reliable, and unlikely to challenge Jefferson or shoot anyone. Perfect!
Clinton's role was mostly ceremonial because Jefferson kept tight control. Unlike modern VPs, he didn't even attend cabinet meetings. His main job? Presiding over Senate debates and breaking tie votes. He did this six times during Jefferson's second term, including approving the Embargo Act of 1807 - which Jefferson later admitted was a mistake.
Why Clinton Gets Overlooked
Let's be real: Clinton's legacy suffers because he followed a human tornado like Burr. Plus, he served during Jefferson's less glamorous second term, dominated by foreign policy failures like the Chesapeake-Leopard Affair and the unpopular embargo. There's also his personality - dutiful but colorless. One historian described him as "the embodiment of the machine politician."
Still, Clinton broke important ground:
- First VP to serve under two presidents (Jefferson and Madison)
- Set precedent for VP as senior statesman rather than heir apparent
- Demonstrated party loyalty mattered more than personal brilliance
Honestly? I think Clinton's underrated. He brought stability when Jefferson desperately needed it. His death in office in 1812 made him the first VP to die while serving - a sad end for a steady hand.
Head-to-Head: Jefferson's Two Vice Presidents Compared
| Category | Aaron Burr (1801-1805) | George Clinton (1805-1809) |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship with Jefferson | Hostile - never trusted after 1800 election crisis | Respectful but distant - Jefferson controlled all decisions |
| Political Experience | NY Attorney General, US Senator | Longest-serving NY Governor (1777-1795, 1801-1804) |
| Public Persona | Charismatic but scandal-prone | Dependable but uncharismatic |
| Major Crisis Managed | Presided over Samuel Chase impeachment trial | Handled Senate debates during Embargo Act fallout |
| Jefferson's Trust Level | Zero - excluded from all decision-making | Moderate - consulted on patronage appointments |
| Post-VP Career | Acquitted of treason, exiled to Europe | Re-elected as Madison's VP, died in office |
What Did Vice Presidents Actually Do in Jefferson's Era?
Modern VP's have West Wing offices and global diplomacy roles. Back then? The job description basically said: "Show up at the Senate occasionally, and try not to shoot anyone." Article I, Section 3 of the Constitution only gave VPs two duties:
- Preside over the Senate (can't debate, only breaks ties)
- Replace POTUS if he dies/resigns (hadn't happened yet)
Jefferson intentionally kept both Burr and Clinton weak. He established the precedent that VPs:
- Wouldn't attend cabinet meetings
- Wouldn't receive classified intelligence
- Wouldn't advise on policy
- Wouldn't travel internationally as administration representatives
Ironically, this created the perfect conditions for Burr's mischief. With no real responsibilities, he spent his VP years networking with Federalists and plotting revenge against Hamilton. Jefferson later admitted this was a mistake - one he corrected with Clinton by assigning him minor patronage duties.
Why Jefferson's VP Choices Matter Today
Those chaotic years permanently shaped American politics. Seriously, next time you see Kamala Harris casting a tie-breaking vote, you're seeing Jefferson's legacy. Three key takeaways:
"The Burr fiasco scared politicians so much that we still separate presidential and VP ballots two centuries later. That's how badly they screwed up!"
The VP role evolved directly from Jefferson's experiences:
- Power Balancing: After Burr, parties learned to pick VPs who complemented rather than challenged presidents
- Scandal Avoidance: Clinton set the "clean and boring" VP template followed by many successors
- Constitutional Safeguards: The 12th Amendment prevents election chaos to this day
Your Top Questions About Thomas Jefferson's Vice Presidents
Did Jefferson and Burr ever reconcile after the presidency?
Not a chance. When Burr returned from European exile in 1812, Jefferson barred him from Monticello. They exchanged frosty letters about financial matters only. Burr spent his final years practicing law in New York, dying in 1836 - ironically, on the same day Texas declared independence from Mexico.
Who took over when George Clinton died as vice president?
Nobody! The office remained vacant for nearly a year until Elbridge Gerry became Madison's second VP. This exposed another flaw: no constitutional provision for replacing VPs until the 25th Amendment in 1967. Clinton's 1812 death created the longest VP vacancy in U.S. history.
Where are Jefferson's vice presidents buried?
Burr's at Princeton Cemetery in New Jersey - just yards from his duel victim Hamilton's son. Clinton's grave is in Kingston, New York. Kinda poetic they rest in different states, reflecting their different personalities.
Did any of Jefferson's VPs become president?
No. Burr came closest in 1800, but Clinton was too old by 1808. Jefferson's successor was his protégé James Madison, with Clinton remaining as VP. Madison later had two VPs die in office - Clinton and Elbridge Gerry.
How often does the VP break Senate ties?
Jefferson's VPs cast 7 tie-breaking votes combined. Burr set the record with 31 tie-breakers in four years - still unbeaten! Modern VPs rarely need to; Mike Pence cast 13, Kamala Harris has cast over 30.
Visiting Historical Sites Today
Want to walk in these guys' footsteps? Here's where to go:
Hamilton-Burr Duel Site (Weehawken, NJ): Overlooks Manhattan where the fatal duel occurred. No museum, just a plaque. Free access dawn to dusk. Take PATH train to Hoboken then Uber. Bring binoculars - the view's incredible.
Clinton House (Poughkeepsie, NY): His pre-gubernatorial home. Open weekends 10am-4pm. Admission $7 adults. Shows his law office and 1780s furnishings. Less flashy than Jefferson's Monticello but more authentic somehow.
Burr's NYC Townhouse Site: 23 Wall Street, now occupied by J.P. Morgan building. Look for plaque near entrance. Pro tip: Visit Stone Street taverns afterward - Burr definitely drank here.
The Lasting Impact of Jefferson's Vice Presidents
It's fascinating how two such different men helped define this awkward office. Burr showed how dangerous an ambitious VP could be, while Clinton proved a loyal subordinate mattered more than brilliance. Together, they taught us:
- Constitutions need constant updating (hence the 12th Amendment)
- Presidents must integrate VPs to prevent mischief
- Personality matters as much as policy in the executive branch
So next time someone asks "who was Thomas Jefferson's vice president," you'll know it's not just trivia - it's a masterclass in political survival. And honestly? It makes me appreciate how smoothly most modern VP transitions work. After Burr's drama, anything would look good!
Leave a Comments