So you're planning a trip to Edinburgh? Brilliant choice. Honestly, finding the best places to stay in Edinburgh can feel overwhelming at first glance. I remember my first time scrolling endlessly, wondering if I should be near the castle or somewhere quieter. Should I splurge on a fancy hotel or find a cozy B&B? It’s a maze of options. Forget generic lists telling you to "stay centrally." Let’s cut through the noise and talk specifics. We'll break down neighborhoods street by street, compare real prices, discuss transport hassles (because who wants to drag luggage uphill?), and spotlight places locals actually recommend. This isn't just about a bed; it's about getting your Edinburgh experience right from the moment you wake up.
Edinburgh's Heartbeat: Choosing Your Perfect Neighborhood
Edinburgh isn't just one vibe. It's a patchwork of distinct areas, each with its own personality. Picking the wrong spot can mean constant bus rides or missing out on the city's charm. Let's get real about where you'll lay your head.
Old Town: Medieval Magic & Tourist Throngs
Think cobbled lanes, looming closes, and the castle watching over everything. Staying here means history is literally outside your door. It’s atmospheric, absolutely. But... be ready for crowds. Seriously, the Royal Mile in summer feels like a festival itself. Steps everywhere too – pack light shoes and lighter luggage.
Perfect for: First-timers, history buffs, those wanting maximum sights within walking distance. Not ideal for: Quiet seekers, anyone with mobility issues, budget travellers.
| Street/Area Focus | Atmosphere & Vibe | Key Attractions Walkable | Typical Travel Time to Waverley Station | Noise Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Royal Mile (Upper) | High energy, constant buzz, tourist central | Edinburgh Castle (5 min), Camera Obscura (2 min), St Giles' Cathedral (on it) | 15-20 mins downhill | High (day & evening) |
| Grassmarket | Lively, pubs galore, castle views, slightly grittier history | Castle (direct views, steep walk up), Victoria Street (5 min), National Museum (10 min) | 10-15 mins (mostly flat) | High (especially evenings/weekends) |
| Cowgate (Lower) | Edgier, nightlife hub (clubs, live music), less scenic by day | Close to Grassmarket, shorter walk to Holyrood (15 min) | 10 mins | Very High at night |
My Grassmarket Experience: Booked a room with that famous castle view. Wowed at sunset. Less wowed at 2 am when pub-goers were belting tunes below. Earplugs became my best friend. The view? Still worth it, but know what you're signing up for.
New Town: Georgian Grace & Shopping Buzz
Imagine wide streets, elegant squares, and stunning architecture. This is where Edinburgh gets refined. Princes Street is the main shopping drag (great if retail therapy is your thing), George Street is fancier, and Rose Street hides cute pubs. It’s generally flatter than the Old Town, which is a blessing for your feet.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Beautiful Georgian architecture everywhere | Can feel less 'historic' than Old Town |
| Generally flatter terrain - easier walking | Accommodation can be pricier, especially on George St |
| Excellent shopping (Princes St, Multrees Walk luxury brands) | Some streets (Princes St) can be noisy with traffic |
| Great transport links (trams on Princes St) | Fewer hostels/mid-range hotels directly *on* the main streets |
| Calmer than Old Town at night (except immediate pub areas) |
Finding the best places to stay in Edinburgh often leads people to New Town for that blend of elegance and convenience. Rose Street Lane is a sneaky-good spot – quieter than Princes Street but steps away. Some flats here offer incredible space compared to Old Town shoeboxes.
Beyond the Centre: Where Locals Escape (& You Might Too)
Okay, the centre is great for ticking boxes. But honestly? Some of Edinburgh's best bits lie just outside. If you want a different rhythm, consider these:
Stockbridge: Village Charm in the City
This is where I wish I lived. Imagine delis, indie boutiques, the Sunday flea market, and the Water of Leith walkway. It feels like a little village plopped into the city. You won't find big hotels here – think charming guesthouses, apartments, and upscale B&Bs. It’s about a 20-25 minute walk to Princes Street, or a quick bus ride (lots of routes).
Downside? Fewer late-night dining options, and that walk back from the centre feels longer after a full day.
Leith: Portside Cool & Culinary Hub
Leith's renaissance is real. The Shore area is fantastic – seafood restaurants (Michelin-starred The Kitchin!), cool bars, and a definite maritime vibe. It’s further out (bus/tram takes 20-25 mins to centre), but that means better value for money, especially for modern apartments. The Royal Yacht Britannia is the big draw here.
Is it one of the best places to stay in Edinburgh for everyone? Maybe not for a first-time, sightseeing-packed weekend. But if you want character, great food, and a local feel, absolutely. Some areas away from The Shore can still be a bit gritty, so pick your spot.
Bruntsfield/Morningside: Leafy & Local
South of the Meadows park, these affluent areas offer a peaceful, residential vibe with lovely cafes, bakeries (hello, Morningside pastry shops!), and independent shops. Very family-friendly. You'll be relying on buses (15-20 mins to centre). Accommodation is mostly B&Bs and self-catering. Perfect for a relaxed pace.
| Neighborhood Comparison Cheat Sheet | Best For... | Average Price Tier | Walk to Princes Street | Primary Vibe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Old Town (Royal Mile) | Ultimate convenience, history lovers | £££ High | 10-20 mins | Historic, Tourist Central |
| Old Town (Grassmarket) | Pub scene, castle views | ££ - £££ Mid to High | 10-15 mins | Lively, Atmospheric |
| New Town (Princes/George St) | Shopping, elegance, transport | £££ High | On it / 5 mins | Grand, Cosmopolitan |
| Stockbridge | Village charm, relaxed pace | ££ - £££ Mid to High | 20-25 mins | Quaint, Local |
| Leith (The Shore) | Foodies, maritime atmosphere, value | ££ Mid | 40+ mins (use bus/tram) | Trendy, Regenerated |
| Bruntsfield/Morningside | Families, peace & quiet, local life | ££ Mid | 30+ mins (use bus) | Leafy, Affluent |
Digging Deeper: Accommodation Types - What REALLY Works?
Beyond location, what kind of pillow will you rest your head on? Each option has its quirks in Edinburgh.
Hotels: From Grand to Functional
Edinburgh has the full spectrum. Iconic grand dames like The Balmoral (clock tower landmark on Princes Street, expect ££££+) offer pure luxury. Boutique hotels like The Dunstane Houses (Haymarket, stylish, unique decor) provide character. Big chains (Premier Inn, Ibis) near Haymarket or Leith offer predictability and often better value for simple stays.
- Pros: Services (reception, housekeeping, often breakfast), amenities (might have gym/spa), security.
- Cons: Can be expensive (especially city centre), often smaller rooms, less local feel.
Finding the best places to stay in Edinburgh within hotels means checking proximity to tram/bus stops if not central. Haymarket is a great transport hub with decent hotel options slightly cheaper than Princes Street.
B&Bs & Guesthouses: Home Comforts & Personal Touch
This is where Edinburgh shines. Think Victorian townhouses in Newington or Stockbridge, friendly owners, and hearty Scottish breakfasts. Places like 94DR in Bruntsfield get rave reviews. You get personality and local tips you won't find online.
- Pros: Warm atmosphere, often spacious rooms, excellent breakfast included, local insight.
- Cons: Might have shared bathrooms (check!), stricter check-in times, possible noise from other guests.
Book well ahead! The good ones vanish fast. Read recent reviews about noise levels and breakfast quality.
Apartment Rentals (Airbnb/VRBO): Live Like a Local
Want a kitchen or more space? Apartments are massive in Edinburgh. Can be fantastic value for groups/families. Look for well-reviewed hosts with responsive communication.
- Pros: Space, self-catering (saves money), laundry facilities (often), local neighbourhood immersion.
- Cons: Lack of services (no daily cleaning/reception), check-in logistics (key collection), variable quality/accuracy.
Watch Out: Edinburgh has strict short-term let regulations. Ensure the host has a license number listed (it's legally required). Avoid 'hidden' listings without reviews. Flats on the top floor (3rd/4th) in Old Town mean STAIRS. Many buildings lack lifts (elevators). Seriously, consider your luggage.
Hostels: Budget Kings & Social Vibes
Not just for backpackers anymore! Edinburgh has excellent hostels like Kick Ass Grassmarket (lively, great location, some private rooms) or Safestay Edinburgh Royal Mile (more central, historic building). Great for solo travellers wanting company.
- Pros: Super budget-friendly, social events, central locations, often have private rooms.
- Cons: Shared facilities, potential noise, less privacy, security (use lockers!).
Check if breakfast is included or cheaply available. Lockers are essential – bring your own padlock.
Your Budget & Edinburgh: Making the Pounds Make Sense
Let's talk money. Edinburgh isn't cheap, especially July-August (Festival!) and Christmas/New Year. But you can navigate it.
| Budget Tier (Per Room/Night) | What to Expect | Likely Locations | Accommodation Types | Tips |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| £ Budget (Under £80) | Basic private room in hostel, small B&B room *maybe* with shared bath, budget chain hotel room *outside centre*. Tempered expectations. | Leith, Haymarket, Southside (near Uni), some outer suburbs. *Rare* in Old/New Town centre. | Hostels (private rooms), very basic B&Bs/Guesthouses, budget chains (Premier Inn/Ibis *advance deals*). | Book *very* far ahead, especially summer. Be flexible on location. Hostel privates offer best value central-ish. |
| ££ Mid-Range (£80 - £160) | Solid choice! Comfortable B&B en-suite, 3-4* hotel room (often chain), well-located apartment. Good balance of comfort/location. | Grassmarket, New Town fringes, Bruntsfield, Stockbridge, Newington, Haymarket, Leith Shore. *Possible* small Old Town rooms or New Town guesthouses. | Quality B&Bs/Guesthouses, 3-4* hotels (incl chains), reliable apartment rentals. | Prime booking window is 3-6 months ahead. Compare B&Bs vs hotels carefully. Apartments great for longer stays/groups. |
| £££ Upper Mid-Range (£160 - £250) | More spacious rooms, boutique hotels, luxury B&Bs, very nice apartments. Expect comfort and style. | New Town (George St, St Andrew Sq), Old Town quality hotels, Stockbridge top B&Bs, best Leith Shore apartments. | Boutique hotels, luxury guesthouses, top-rated apartments. | Look for deals/direct booking discounts. Consider slightly off-centre luxury for better value (e.g., Dunstane Houses). |
| ££££ Luxury (£250+) | The best. Iconic hotels (Balmoral, Scotsman, Witchery), exceptional boutique, palatial apartments. Service & location paramount. | Princes Street, George Street, Royal Mile (The Witchery), St Andrew Square. | 5* hotels, unique luxury suites (like Witchery), highest-end serviced apartments. | Book direct with hotel for potential perks. Understand what 'luxury' means to you (history? spa? views?). |
Festival Season Reality Check (August): Honestly? Double those prices. That £80 budget room? More like £160. That £150 nice hotel? £300+. Book at least 9 months ahead. Seriously. Consider staying slightly further out (Leith, Bruntsfield) and using buses/trams. Day tickets are your friend.
Timing is Everything: When Edinburgh Changes its Prices (& Vibe)
When you visit massively impacts cost and availability. Forget just "high season".
| Season | Typical Dates | What's Happening | Accommodation Impact | Vibe & Tips |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peak Peak! | August (Edinburgh Fringe Festival + Int'l Festival + Tattoo) | The city EXPLODES. Thousands of shows, street performers, packed streets. Electric atmosphere. | Prices are astronomical (easily 2-3x normal). Availability vanishes up to a year ahead. Minimum stays common (3-7 nights). | Book accommodation NOW if planning for next year. Expect crowds everywhere. Embrace the chaos or avoid it! |
| High Season | July, Late May - June, September (especially weekends), Christmas & New Year | Main tourist season. Good weather (hopefully), long days (June). Christmas markets & Hogmanay madness. | Prices high. Booking 4-6+ months ahead essential, especially for popular types/locations. | Great time for weather and events. Book early. Hogmanay (NYE) requires specific tickets/accommodation packages. |
| Shoulder Seasons | April - Early May, Late September - October | Potentially great weather, fewer crowds than summer. Autumn colours can be stunning. | Prices moderate. Good availability if booked 2-3 months ahead. Fewer minimum stays. | Potentially the sweet spot! Good balance of cost, weather, and crowds. Check Easter dates. |
| Low Season | November (excl. end), January - March | Coldest, darkest, wettest months. Fewer tourists. | Lowest prices. Best deals and widest availability. Can book closer to trip. | Ideal for budget travellers, indoor attractions (museums!), cosy pub vibes. Wrap up warm! Short daylight hours. |
Getting Around: Your Edinburgh Transport Cheat Sheet
Location impacts transport needs. Let's demystify it.
- Walking: Old Town, New Town, Stockbridge, Bruntsfield are all very walkable *within* themselves. Walking *between* central areas (Old Town to New Town) is easy (5-15 mins). Walking to Leith from centre? It's a hike (40+ mins).
- Buses (Lothian Buses): The workhorse. Extensive network. Buy tickets on board (exact change helpful, contactless card best - capped daily). Day tickets (£5 adult) are brilliant if making multiple trips. Apps (Transport for Edinburgh) show real-time arrivals. Key routes: Airport Airlink 100, Princes Street to Leith (e.g., 16, 22, 35).
- Trams: Run from Airport through West End, Princes Street, St Andrew Square to York Place (New Town). Expanding to Leith soon! Great for Airport transfers and north-south New Town axis. More expensive than bus (£7.50 adult Airport single, £2 single city zone), but smooth.
- Taxis/Ride Shares (Uber/Bolt): Plentiful. Useful late at night or with luggage. Can get expensive across town.
If you stumble upon the best places to stay in Edinburgh slightly out of centre, plug the postcode into Google Maps and check bus routes/times to key sights *before* booking. A 'cheap' hotel with a £10 daily taxi ride isn't cheap.
Final Tips: Booking Smart & Avoiding Regrets
- Book Direct (Sometimes): For hotels/B&Bs, check their own website. They might offer a discount, free breakfast, or room upgrade not on Booking.com. Always compare.
- Filter Wisely: On booking sites, use filters ruthlessly: Free Cancellation (lifesaver!), Review Score (8.0+ generally good), Specific Neighbourhood, Property Type.
- Read Recent Reviews: Focus on mentions of noise (street, thin walls), cleanliness, bed comfort, Wi-Fi speed (crucial!), and host responsiveness (for rentals). Look for photos uploaded by guests.
- Check the Map *Precisely*: That "New Town" apartment might actually be way up near Stockbridge. Use the map view and measure walking distance/time to your must-see places.
- Manage Expectations (Old Town): Rooms can be small, quirky, and stairs are inevitable (often narrow and winding). It's part of the charm, but not for everyone.
My Biggest Mistake: Booked a 'central' Old Town apartment sight unseen once. Pictures looked cute. Reality? The 'double' bed was two singles shoved together in a room barely wider than the bed itself. The shower was in the kitchen. Lesson learned: scrutinize room descriptions and *all* photos, especially regarding bed size and bathroom setup!
Your Best Places to Stay in Edinburgh Questions Answered (FAQ)
What is the best area in Edinburgh for first-time visitors?
For sheer convenience and immersion, Old Town (Royal Mile or Grassmarket) or New Town (near Princes Street) are hard to beat. You're walking distance to the castle, Scott Monument, shops, and countless restaurants. The buzz is right there. Just be prepared for higher prices and crowds, especially on the Royal Mile itself. If those cons worry you, look at the West End (fringes of New Town) or the Southside (near the University - lots of good value).
Where should I stay in Edinburgh to avoid crowds?
Look beyond the immediate centre. Stockbridge feels like a village and gets busy on market day but is generally calmer. Bruntsfield/Morningside are very residential and peaceful. Leith (away from The Shore on weeknights) has good local spots. Even within the centre, streets just *off* the Royal Mile (like Chambers Street or the top of Victoria Street) are noticeably quieter.
Is it better to stay in Old Town or New Town Edinburgh?
It depends on your vibe! Old Town is medieval history, narrow closes, atmospheric but can be noisy and hilly. New Town is Georgian elegance, wider streets, great shopping, generally flatter terrain. Both are central. Old Town feels more uniquely 'Edinburgh', New Town feels grander. Can't decide? Stay near the bridge connecting them (North Bridge or George IV Bridge)!
What is the best month to visit Edinburgh?
For the best balance of decent weather, manageable crowds, and fair prices, aim for late April/May or September/October. June/July have the longest days but are busier. August is Festival madness (amazing but overwhelming and expensive). December is magical for Christmas markets but cold and busy. Winter (Jan-Mar) is cheapest but coldest/darkest.
How many days in Edinburgh is enough?
3 full days is a solid minimum to hit the big sights (Castle, Holyrood Palace, Royal Mile, Calton Hill, National Museum) without rushing. 4-5 days lets you explore deeper (walk the Water of Leith, visit Leith, maybe a day trip to South Queensferry for the bridges). With less than 3, you'll be very selective or constantly on the go.
Where should I stay in Edinburgh without a car?
Absolutely anywhere central or well-connected by bus/tram. You don't want a car in central Edinburgh (traffic, expensive parking). Focus on areas near Lothian Bus routes or the tram line (currently to York Place, soon Leith). Old Town, New Town, Stockbridge, Bruntsfield, Leith (near tram stops or major bus routes like Leith Walk) are all fine without a car. Avoid truly suburban locations unless you know the bus frequency is good.
Where to stay in Edinburgh for the Fringe Festival?
Book extremely early (like 9-12 months ahead). Anywhere central (Old Town, New Town) will be insanely expensive. Look further out but on good transport links: Haymarket (tram/bus hub), Bruntsfield/Morningside (frequent buses), Leith (buses/tram extension). Factor in the cost/time of daily transport. Consider hostels or apartment shares. Expect minimum stays (5-7 nights).
Wrapping It Up: Your Edinburgh Stay Starts Here
Figuring out the best places to stay in Edinburgh isn't just about a pin on a map. It's about matching the location and the bed to *your* trip. Are you here to dive headfirst into history, ticking off every castle and close? Maybe Grassmarket or Upper Royal Mile is your jam (earplugs recommended). Want elegance and ease with stunning architecture? New Town calls. Craving a local vibe away from the shuffle? Stockbridge or Leith deliver. On a tight budget? Hostels or smart apartment finds in Leith or near Haymarket make it work.
The key? Be honest about what matters most – budget, location buzz vs quiet, space, ease of transport – and book early, especially for summer or festivals. Read those recent reviews carefully, especially about noise and bed size (trust me!). Use the transport links smartly. Edinburgh rewards a bit of planning. Now get out there and find your perfect Edinburgh base. You're going to love this city.
Leave a Comments